How to roll over a 403(b)
Last updated August 2026
Short answer
403(b) plans grew out of tax-sheltered annuities, and the products are still there. That is where the difference from an ordinary rollover lives.
Find the surrender charge first
Annuity contracts commonly apply a charge to amounts withdrawn or transferred within a set number of years, sometimes declining annually.
The charge applies to a rollover, not just to cash withdrawals, so it is deducted from what actually reaches the new account.
Waiting for a surrender period to end is sometimes worth more than the fee saving from moving early, which is a calculation worth doing rather than guessing.
Decide the destination
An IRA gives full investment choice and simpler distributions later.
A new employer's plan preserves the rule of 55 and keeps pre-tax money out of the pro-rata calculation for a backdoor Roth.
A governmental 457(b) that accepts rollovers is another option, though rolling into one does not give the incoming money the 457(b) penalty exemption.
The contract exchange alternative
If you are still employed and unhappy with the vendor, an exchange to a different provider inside the same plan may be available.
That keeps the money in the 403(b) while changing the underlying contract, which is how many participants escape high-cost annuities without leaving the job.
Plans vary in which vendors they permit, and the list is usually published by the employer rather than by the provider you currently hold.
Try it in Walnut
Walnut connects to your brokerage and reads the receiving IRA, so a rollover lands somewhere visible alongside the rest of your portfolio.
Requesting the rollover
Open the receiving account first, since the provider will ask for the account number.
Request a direct rollover explicitly, and check that any cheque is payable to the new custodian for your benefit rather than to you.
Keep Roth and pre-tax balances separate through the move, because mixing them creates an accidental taxable conversion.
Timing and paperwork
Expect two to four weeks, longer where a paper cheque or a signature guarantee is involved.
The balance is generally liquidated and held in cash during the transfer, so it is out of the market for that period.
The old provider issues a Form 1099-R that should show a direct rollover rather than a taxable distribution, and it is worth checking the code when it arrives.
After it lands
Confirm the amount matches the closing statement, net of any surrender charge you were expecting.
Invest the cash rather than leaving it in a settlement fund.
Set beneficiaries on the new account, since designations do not travel with the money.
Whether the move is worth making at all
Add the annual cost you are paying now: fund expense ratio plus any annuity wrapper fee plus plan charges.
Compare that against the same exposure in an IRA, then weigh the surrender charge as a one-off against the annual saving.
A 1% annual difference on a large balance repays a several-hundred-dollar surrender charge quickly. On a small balance in the last year of a surrender period, waiting usually wins.
Sources
Rollover rules, withholding and the 60-day window are published by the IRS at Rollovers of retirement plan and IRA distributions, with 403(b) plan rules including exchanges in Publication 571. Walnut is informational and is not an investment adviser. This guide is educational and not personalized tax advice.
FAQ
How do I roll over a 403(b)?
+
Open the receiving account, then request a direct rollover from the 403(b) provider. The money should move trustee to trustee. Before you start, find out whether the contract imposes a surrender charge, which is deducted from what transfers.
What is a surrender charge?
+
A fee some annuity contracts apply to amounts withdrawn or transferred within a set number of years, often on a declining scale. It applies to a rollover as much as to a cash withdrawal, and it reduces the balance that reaches the new account.
Where can I roll it to?
+
An IRA, a new employer's 403(b) or 401(k), or a governmental 457(b) that accepts incoming rollovers. Roth 403(b) balances should go to a Roth destination rather than a traditional one.
Can I roll over while still working?
+
Some plans permit in-service distributions or transfers, frequently after a stated age, and many do not. If you are unhappy with the provider, an in-plan exchange to a different vendor inside the same 403(b) is sometimes possible without leaving the job.
What is a 90-24 or contract exchange?
+
A transfer between vendors inside the same 403(b) plan, which keeps the money in the plan while changing the underlying contract. It is the route for escaping an expensive provider without a distributable event.
Will there be tax?
+
Not on a direct rollover between pre-tax accounts, or between Roth accounts. A distribution paid to you triggers 20% withholding and a 60-day deadline to replace it, so always ask for the direct route.
Should I roll it at all?
+
Compare the costs. A 403(b) with a low-cost custodial account can be cheaper than an IRA. A contract with annuity wrapper fees and mediocre funds usually is not, and the surrender charge is the price of leaving.
What happens to a loan?
+
An outstanding loan generally has to be repaid on separation, and an unpaid balance is treated as a distribution. You may be able to contribute an equivalent amount to an IRA by the tax filing deadline to avoid the tax.
How do I decide whether the surrender charge is worth paying?
+
Compare it against the annual saving. A one percentage point difference in ongoing costs on a large balance repays a few hundred dollars quickly, while on a small balance in the final year of a surrender period, waiting is usually cheaper.