ETF comparisons

Last updated November 2026

Short answer

These are the most-searched ETF head-to-heads, each compared on what the two funds track, their expense ratios, dividend yields, how much their holdings overlap, and who each suits. Two funds that look similar can own very different things, or own almost the same things at different costs, so the right pick depends on what you already hold. Pick a pair below.

What to compare between two ETFs

Two funds can look almost interchangeable on the surface and behave very differently, or look different and be nearly the same trade. Line up any pair on four things and the real distinction appears:

  • Cost. The expense ratio is the annual fee. When two funds track the same index, cost is often the main thing separating them, and the gap compounds over decades. A 0.03 percent fund and a 0.09 percent fund holding the same index are effectively the same bet at different prices.
  • Holdings and index. What does each fund actually own, and which index does it track? Fund names can mislead here. Two S&P 500 funds hold the same 500 companies; a growth fund and a value fund with similar sizes hold almost none of the same names.
  • Overlap. How much do the two funds hold in common? Overlap decides whether owning both adds diversification or just duplicates exposure. It is the single most important axis when the comparison is between a fund you are considering and one you already own.
  • Size and liquidity. Assets under management and trading volume affect bid-ask spreads and the odds a fund stays open. Between near-identical funds, the larger, more heavily traded one is often the more practical hold.

Dividend yield matters too when income is the goal, but for most head-to-heads, cost, holdings, overlap, and size settle the question.

How to read an ETF comparison

Each pair below is compared on the same axes, so you can see at a glance whether two funds are the same exposure at different prices or genuinely different bets. The most useful comparison is rarely between two funds in the abstract. It is between a fund you are considering and the funds you already hold.

When two funds track the same index, treat the comparison as a cost-and-liquidity decision and move on. When the indexes differ, focus on holdings and overlap: a technology-heavy fund stacked on top of a market fund that is already technology-heavy can quietly concentrate your portfolio, while a fund with genuinely different exposure can broaden it. That portfolio-fit question, how a fund overlaps with what you already own, is exactly what Walnut is built to answer once you connect your broker.

VOO vs VTIS&P 500 vs Morningstar US total market (formerly CRSP US Total Market)

VOO holds only the S&P 500's large caps, while VTI owns the entire US market including mid and small caps, at the same 0.03% fee. VTI is the more diversified single-fund core; VOO is the cleaner large-cap bet, and the two overlap heavily at the top.

VOO vs SPYSame index, different cost

VOO and SPY track the same S&P 500, so returns are nearly identical before fees. VOO is cheaper (0.03% vs 0.0945%), which favors long-term holders, while SPY's far deeper options market and liquidity is what active traders and hedgers pay the premium for.

IVV vs VOOSame index, different cost

IVV and VOO track the same S&P 500 at the same 0.03% fee, so their exposure and returns are functionally identical. The choice is really iShares (BlackRock) versus Vanguard as an ecosystem rather than any performance edge.

QQQ vs VOONasdaq-100 vs S&P 500

QQQ tracks the tech-heavy Nasdaq-100 (0.18%), while VOO tracks the broad S&P 500 (0.03%). QQQ is a more concentrated, more volatile growth tilt; VOO is the cheaper, more diversified core, and QQQ excludes financials and most non-Nasdaq names entirely.

QQQ vs VGTNasdaq-100 vs MSCI US IMI Information Technology 25/50

QQQ is the Nasdaq-100, which includes large non-tech names across consumer and healthcare, while VGT is a pure information-technology sector fund. VGT is more concentrated in tech and cheaper (around 0.09% vs 0.18%); QQQ is broader but excludes financials.

VGT vs XLKMSCI US IMI Information Technology 25/50 vs Technology Select Sector

VGT and XLK both target US technology, but VGT holds a broader roster including mid and small-cap tech, while XLK covers only the tech names inside the S&P 500 and is more top-heavy. Fees are similar; VGT gives more breadth, XLK more mega-cap concentration.

VUG vs SCHGCRSP US Large Cap Growth vs Dow Jones US Large-Cap Growth Total Stock Market

VUG and SCHG are both low-cost large-cap growth funds with heavily overlapping holdings and similar returns. The differences come down to the exact index methodology and number of names; neither has a durable edge over the other.

SCHG vs MGKDow Jones US Large-Cap Growth Total Stock Market vs CRSP US Mega Cap Growth

SCHG covers a broad slice of large-cap growth, while MGK concentrates on mega-cap growth only, so MGK is more top-heavy in the largest names. SCHG gives more breadth; MGK leans harder into the very biggest growth companies.

VOO vs VUGS&P 500 vs CRSP US Large Cap Growth

VOO holds the whole S&P 500, while VUG holds only its growth half, so VUG is more concentrated in technology and more volatile. VOO is the balanced core; VUG is a growth tilt layered on top of that exposure.

SCHD vs VYMDow Jones US Dividend 100 vs FTSE High Dividend Yield

SCHD uses a quality-and-dividend screen that tilts toward stronger balance sheets and dividend growth, while VYM casts a wider net across high-yield large caps. SCHD is more concentrated and growth-tilted; VYM holds more names at a broadly similar yield.

JEPI vs SCHDActively managed (no index) vs Dow Jones US Dividend 100

JEPI generates income from a covered-call options overlay, producing a high headline yield but capping upside, while SCHD is a straightforward dividend-quality equity fund with full equity upside and a lower yield. They are different tools: income smoothing versus dividend-growth ownership.

VOO vs SCHDS&P 500 vs Dow Jones US Dividend 100

VOO owns the entire large-cap market including high-growth tech, while SCHD is a dividend-quality subset that tilts toward value and income. VOO captures more of the market's growth; SCHD trades some of that for higher current yield and a value lean.

SMH vs SOXXMVIS US Listed Semiconductor 25 vs NYSE Semiconductor (formerly ICE Semiconductor)

SMH and SOXX both track semiconductors, but SMH is more concentrated in its largest holding (NVIDIA-heavy) and a tighter roster, while SOXX spreads across more chip names. SMH amplifies the leaders; SOXX is the more evenly distributed bet.

IWM vs VOORussell 2000 vs S&P 500

IWM tracks small-cap US stocks (Russell 2000), while VOO tracks large-cap (S&P 500), so they sit at opposite ends of the size spectrum. IWM is more volatile and economically sensitive; VOO is the steadier large-cap core.

DIA vs VOODow Jones Industrial Average vs S&P 500

DIA tracks the 30-stock, price-weighted Dow, while VOO tracks the 500-stock, market-cap-weighted S&P 500. VOO is far broader and weights by company size; DIA is narrower and quirkily weighted by share price rather than market cap.

ARKK vs QQQActively managed (no index) vs Nasdaq-100

ARKK is an actively managed, high-conviction disruption fund with a high fee (around 0.75%) and large swings, while QQQ is a passive, rules-based Nasdaq-100 index at 0.18%. ARKK is a concentrated active bet; QQQ is broad big-tech beta.

SPLG vs VOOSame index, different cost

SPLG and VOO both track the S&P 500 with essentially identical exposure, so returns are nearly the same. SPLG (which now trades under the ticker SPYM) has a fee that is a touch lower (0.02% vs 0.03%) and its share price is smaller, which some prefer for exact-dollar buying; the two are interchangeable as a core holding.

RSP vs VOOS&P 500 Equal Weight vs S&P 500

RSP holds the same S&P 500 companies but weights them equally, while VOO weights by market cap, so VOO is dominated by a few megacaps and RSP is not. RSP gives more exposure to the average large-cap and less single-name risk at a higher 0.20% fee; VOO is cheaper and rides the biggest winners harder.

JEPQ vs JEPINasdaq-100 (active equity + options overlay) vs Actively managed (no index)

JEPQ runs its covered-call income strategy on Nasdaq-100 stocks, while JEPI runs a similar strategy on a broader, lower-volatility S&P 500 selection. JEPQ tends to yield more and swing more because tech is more volatile; JEPI is the steadier, more diversified income sibling.

AGG vs BNDBloomberg US Aggregate Bond Index vs Bloomberg US Aggregate Float Adjusted Index

AGG and BND both track the total US investment-grade bond market with very similar holdings and the same 0.03% fee, so their returns track closely. The choice is really iShares (BlackRock) versus Vanguard; either works as a one-fund core bond allocation.

TLT vs BNDICE US Treasury 20+ Year Bond Index vs Bloomberg US Aggregate Float Adjusted Index

TLT holds only long-dated (20+ year) Treasuries, so it is far more sensitive to interest rates than BND, which spreads across the whole investment-grade market at shorter average maturity. TLT is a concentrated rate and recession bet; BND is a diversified, steadier core bond holding.

GLD vs SLVLBMA Gold Price (physical gold) vs LBMA Silver Price (physical silver)

GLD holds physical gold and SLV holds physical silver. Gold is more of a pure store-of-value and crisis hedge, while silver carries heavy industrial demand (solar, electronics) that makes SLV more volatile and more tied to the economic cycle. Neither pays income.

FTEC vs VGTMSCI USA IMI Information Technology 25/50 Index vs MSCI US IMI Information Technology 25/50

FTEC and VGT are both broad US technology sector funds with heavily overlapping holdings (NVIDIA, Apple, Microsoft) and similar low fees. Differences come down to index provider and the exact roster; neither has a durable edge, so the pick often follows whichever brokerage ecosystem you use.

SCHX vs VOODow Jones US Large-Cap Total Stock Market Index vs S&P 500

SCHX tracks a slightly broader large-cap universe (around 750 names) while VOO tracks the S&P 500's 500, but top holdings and returns are nearly identical at the same 0.03% fee. SCHX is Schwab's core large-cap fund; VOO is Vanguard's. Functionally interchangeable.

VIG vs VUGS&P US Dividend Growers vs CRSP US Large Cap Growth

VIG holds about 340 US companies that have raised their dividends for at least 10 straight years (0.05% fee, about 1.7% yield), while VUG holds the growth half of US large caps (0.03%, 0.38% yield). VUG put about 36% in NVIDIA, Apple and Microsoft and was roughly 58% technology as of October 2026, against about 13.5% in VIG's top three, so VIG is the more sector-balanced dividend-growth fund and VUG the concentrated growth bet.

SCHD vs VIGDow Jones US Dividend 100 vs S&P US Dividend Growers

Both screen US stocks on a 10-year dividend record, but differently. SCHD holds 100 names picked for payment history, cash flow to debt, return on equity and yield (0.06%, about 3.2% yield), while VIG holds about 340 companies that have raised dividends for 10 straight years and skips the highest yielders (0.05%, about 1.7%). SCHD leans toward income and value; VIG toward dividend growth, with Microsoft, Apple and Broadcom at the top.

VXUS vs VIGIFTSE Global All Cap ex US vs an index of non-US companies with a record of raising their dividends

VXUS owns essentially the whole non-US stock market, roughly 8,500 companies across developed and emerging markets, at 0.05%. VIGI narrows that to non-US companies with a record of raising dividends, at 0.07% and $9.2B in assets, which leaves it about 30% financials. Despite the dividend label, VIGI's 2.21% yield was slightly below VXUS's (about 2.3%) as of October 2026, because it screens for dividend growth, not yield.

IXUS vs VXUSMSCI ACWI ex USA IMI vs FTSE Global All Cap ex US

IXUS and VXUS are both one-fund international cores covering developed and emerging markets in large, mid and small caps, with Taiwan Semiconductor as the top holding in each. VXUS follows the FTSE Global All Cap ex US index (about 8,500 stocks, 0.05%) and IXUS the MSCI ACWI ex USA IMI (about 4,000 to 4,400 stocks, 0.07%). One quirk: FTSE counts South Korea as developed and MSCI as emerging. Either works; the pick usually follows your brokerage.

VT vs VXUSFTSE Global All Cap vs FTSE Global All Cap ex US

VT owns the whole world stock market, roughly 9,500 companies at about 60% US and 40% non-US, for 0.07%. VXUS is only the non-US part (about 8,500 stocks, 0.05%) and holds no US companies. VT is the single-fund answer; VXUS is the international half of a two-fund setup, where pairing it with VTI rebuilds VT and lets you choose your own US and international split.

SHLD vs ITAGlobal X Defense Tech Index vs Dow Jones US Select Aerospace & Defense

SHLD (Global X Defense Tech, 0.50%) holds US and international defense companies, with Palantir its largest position at about 11.8% and European names like BAE Systems, Rheinmetall and Saab in its top 10. ITA (iShares US Aerospace & Defense, 0.37%) holds US companies only, and GE Aerospace alone was about 21% of it as of October 2026. Their top-10 lists share RTX, Lockheed Martin, General Dynamics, Northrop Grumman and L3Harris.

ITA vs XARDow Jones US Select Aerospace & Defense vs S&P Aerospace & Defense Select Industry

ITA and XAR cover the same US aerospace and defense industry with opposite weighting. ITA is cap-weighted, so its top 10 was about 75% of the fund as of October 2026, led by GE Aerospace at about 21%. XAR is equal-weighted, so its top 10 was about 30% and no holding reached 3.5%. Fees are close (0.37% and 0.35%), so the practical difference is how much the largest contractors drive returns.

URA vs URNMSolactive Global Uranium & Nuclear Components Total Return Index vs North Shore Global Uranium Mining Index

URA (Global X Uranium, 0.69%) mixes uranium miners with nuclear component makers and reactor developers, while URNM (Sprott Uranium Miners, 0.75%) sticks to miners and companies that hold physical uranium. Cameco is the largest position in both, at about 22% of URA and 20% of URNM as of October 2026. URNM is more concentrated, with about 80% of the fund in its top 10 against about 54% for URA.

URA vs NLRSolactive Global Uranium & Nuclear Components Total Return Index vs MVIS Global Uranium & Nuclear Energy Index

URA is mostly the fuel side of nuclear power: uranium miners, led by Cameco. NLR (VanEck Uranium and Nuclear, 0.52%) adds the utilities and engineering firms that run and build reactors, with Constellation Energy its largest holding as of October 2026. NLR is the broader nuclear-energy fund and costs less; URA moves more with the uranium price.

BOTZ vs ROBOIndxx Global Robotics & Artificial Intelligence Thematic vs ROBO Global Robotics & Automation

BOTZ and ROBO share a theme but very few holdings: their top-10 lists overlap only in Intuitive Surgical and Fanuc. BOTZ (Global X, 0.68%) is cap-weighted, with its top 10 at about 57% of the fund and NVIDIA among them. ROBO (ROBO Global, 0.95%) spreads money across many automation companies, so its top 10 was about 15% as of October 2026. BOTZ is the concentrated fund; ROBO the broad and more expensive one.

CIBR vs BUGNasdaq CTA Cybersecurity Index vs Indxx Cybersecurity Index

CIBR (First Trust NASDAQ Cybersecurity, 0.58%) is the largest cybersecurity ETF, at about $17 billion, and holds Broadcom and Cisco alongside the pure security companies. BUG (Global X Cybersecurity, 0.50%) tracks an index of companies that develop and run security software and services, with Okta its largest position as of October 2026. CrowdStrike, Palo Alto Networks, Fortinet and Zscaler appear in both top 10s.

CIBR vs HACKNasdaq CTA Cybersecurity Index vs Prime Cyber Defense Index

CIBR and HACK overlap more than any other pair of cybersecurity ETFs we track: at least 48% of their weight sits in the same top-10 companies, including Broadcom, CrowdStrike, Palo Alto Networks and Cisco. CIBR is far larger (about $17 billion against $3.3 billion) and slightly cheaper (0.58% against 0.60%). Holding both mostly means owning the same companies twice.

SMH vs XSDMVIS US Listed Semiconductor 25 vs S&P Semiconductor Select Industry Index

SMH (VanEck Semiconductor, 0.35%) is cap-weighted around the largest chip companies, with NVIDIA its biggest holding. XSD (SPDR S&P Semiconductor, 0.35%) is equal-weighted, so mid-sized chip designers carry as much weight as the giants and its top 10 was about 27% of the fund as of October 2026. The two share almost none of their top holdings; XSD is the way to own the smaller names SMH barely holds.

UFO vs ARKXS-Network Space Index vs Actively managed

UFO (Procure Space, 0.75%) is an index fund of companies that earn most of their revenue from space, while ARKX (ARK Space & Defense Innovation, 0.75%) is actively managed and also holds aerospace, drone and technology names such as NVIDIA and Amazon. Both had SpaceX and Rocket Lab among their top holdings as of October 2026. UFO is the purer space exposure; ARKX depends on ARK's stock picks.

LIT vs REMXSolactive Global Lithium Index vs MVIS Global Rare Earth/Strategic Metals Index

LIT and REMX are often treated as the same critical-minerals trade, but their top-10 lists shared only Albemarle as of late 2026. LIT (Global X Lithium & Battery Tech, 0.75%) had Rio Tinto at about 23% of the fund plus battery makers and Tesla, while REMX (VanEck, 0.53%) spread across lithium, rare earth, molybdenum and tungsten miners, with no holding above 9%.

FAQ

How do I compare two ETFs?

+

Line them up on five things: the index each tracks, the expense ratio, the dividend yield, how much their top holdings overlap, and who each one suits. Two funds that look alike can own very different portfolios, or own nearly the same portfolio at different costs. Every pair below is compared on exactly those axes.

Which ETF comparison matters most for my portfolio?

+

The one between a fund you are considering and a fund you already own. Overlap is the deciding factor: adding a second S&P 500 fund on top of one you hold changes almost nothing, while adding a different exposure can meaningfully shift your risk. Start from what you already hold, then compare.

Do two ETFs that track the same index perform the same?

+

Nearly, before fees. When two funds track the same index (for example VOO, IVV, and SPLG on the S&P 500), returns are almost identical and the expense ratio becomes the main differentiator, along with trading liquidity. When the indexes differ, holdings and returns can diverge a lot.

What is fund overlap?

+

Fund overlap is the degree to which two ETFs hold the same underlying companies. Two S&P 500 funds overlap almost completely, so owning both changes little. A total-market fund and an S&P 500 fund also overlap heavily, because the large caps dominate both. High overlap means you are not adding diversification, only duplicating exposure, which is the single most useful thing to check before buying a second fund.

VOO vs VTI: which is better?

+

Neither is simply better; they do slightly different jobs. VOO tracks the S&P 500, the 500 largest US companies, while VTI tracks the entire US market including mid and small caps. Their costs are nearly identical and their returns are close because large caps dominate both. VTI is broader; VOO is pure large cap. The choice depends on whether you want small and mid cap exposure. This is general information, not a recommendation.

Does a lower expense ratio always mean a better ETF?

+

Only when the two funds do the same job. Between two S&P 500 funds, the cheaper one is usually the better pick because their holdings are nearly identical. But cost is not comparable across funds with different exposures: a broad-market fund and a thematic fund charge different fees because they own different things. Compare cost within a category, not across categories.

Can Walnut compare ETFs against what I already own?

+

Yes. Connect your broker and Walnut can show how much a fund overlaps with your real holdings, where it adds new exposure, and how it fits your targets. You keep your broker and approve any trade. Walnut is informational and not an investment adviser.

Walnut is informational, not investment advice. ETF figures are approximate and dated; verify current data with each issuer before deciding.