Investor Sentiment Statistics (2026)
Updated November 2026
As of mid-November 2026, retail sentiment leans bearish (AAII bearish 42.2% vs a 31.5% historical average, bullish 33.3%), CNN's Fear & Greed Index has dropped to 16 (extreme fear), and the VIX closed at 28.44 on Nov 19, well above its long-run median of about 17.6. Consumers have brightened from deep lows: the Conference Board index rose to 91.7 in October and Michigan sentiment was 51.5 in November. Professionals remain heavily invested, with fund manager cash at 3.6% (under BofA's 4% sell-signal line) and margin debt at $1.45 trillion in October, below June's record $1.50 trillion.
- Retail investors lean bearish: the AAII survey for the week ending Nov 18, 2026 showed 33.3% bullish, 42.2% bearish, and 24.4% neutral, after 51.4% bearish the week before, with bearishness above its 31.5% historical average and a 53.3% bearish one-year high in mid-September (AAII).
- The market mood gauges read fear: CNN's Fear & Greed Index closed at 16 (extreme fear) on Nov 19, 2026, down from 40 a week earlier, while the VIX closed at 28.44 the same day, its highest close since March and well above its long-run median of about 17.6 (CNN, Cboe).
- Consumers have lifted off their lows: the Conference Board Consumer Confidence Index rose 7.5 points to 91.7 in October, and Michigan sentiment was 51.5 in November, up from 48.0 in October and 51.0 a year earlier (Conference Board, U. Michigan).
- Professionals are still heavily invested: BofA's November fund manager survey put cash at 3.6%, below the bank's 4% contrarian sell-signal line and just above August's record-low 3.5% (BofA via Mace News).
- Leverage remains high: FINRA margin debt was $1.45 trillion in October 2026, up 22.4% year over year but below June's all-time high of $1.50 trillion, and household stock allocation reached a record 45% of financial assets (FINRA).
- Sentiment is a contrarian tool: AAII bullishness peaked at 75% in January 2000 near the dot-com top, and bearishness peaked at 70.3% in March 2009 near the crisis bottom.
Where sentiment stands today
Investor sentiment in November 2026 has turned fearful across the market gauges. Retail investors lean bearish, with AAII bearishness at 42.2% against a 31.5% average, CNN's Fear & Greed Index closed at 16 (extreme fear) on November 19, and the VIX jumped to 28.44 the same day, its highest close since March (see the dashboard below). Consumer confidence, by contrast, has rebounded from September's lows, though it remains below average.
Professionals, meanwhile, remain heavily invested: fund-manager cash fell to 3.6% in November, still under BofA's 4% sell-signal line and just above August's record-low 3.5%, and borrowed money in brokerage accounts sits a little below June's all-time high. Fear in the surveys and prices alongside full positioning is the tension running through every gauge on this page.
| Indicator | Latest reading | Reference | Signal |
|---|---|---|---|
| AAII bearish | 42.2% | Week to Nov 18, 2026 | Pessimistic (avg 31.5%) |
| AAII bullish | 33.3% | Week to Nov 18, 2026 | Below average (avg 37.5%) |
| AAII bull-bear spread | -8.9 pts | Week to Nov 18, 2026 | Negative |
| CNN Fear & Greed | 16 / 100 | Nov 19, 2026 | Extreme Fear |
| VIX | 28.44 | Nov 19, 2026 | Elevated |
| Conference Board confidence | 91.7 | Oct 2026 | Below average |
| Michigan sentiment | 51.5 | Nov 2026 (final) | Historically low |
| NAAIM manager exposure | 77.3 | 2026 | Moderately long |
| BofA fund manager cash | 3.6% | Nov 2026 | Below 4% (sell signal) |
Signals are the standard contrarian/threshold interpretations, not investment advice. Source: AAII, CNN, Cboe, Conference Board, U. Michigan, NAAIM, BofA (via Mace News)
The AAII Sentiment Survey
The American Association of Individual Investors has polled its members weekly since 1987, asking a simple question: are you bullish, bearish, or neutral on stocks over the next six months. In the week ending November 18, 2026, bullishness was 33.3%, bearishness 42.2%, and neutral 24.4% (see the chart below). A week earlier bearishness had reached 51.4%.
For context, the long-run averages are 37.5% bullish, 31.0% neutral, and 31.5% bearish, so today's readings show far more pessimism than usual, below-average optimism, and a squeezed middle ground. Bearishness hit a one-year high of 53.3% in the week ending September 16, 2026. The survey is the most-watched retail sentiment gauge and is widely treated as a contrarian signal at extremes (AAII).
Latest survey (week ending Nov 18, 2026) vs long-run averages. Source: AAII.
The bull-bear spread
Analysts often collapse the AAII survey into one number: the bull-bear spread (bullish minus bearish). In the week ending November 18, 2026 that spread was -8.9 points (33.3% minus 42.2%), up from -20.6 points a week earlier (30.8% bullish, 51.4% bearish). It was -2.9 points in mid-October and +8.8 points in July 2026.
The spread matters because extremes tend to mark turning points. A spread far above +20 has historically clustered near market tops, while deeply negative spreads have appeared near bottoms. The -20.6 reading in the week ending November 11 was one of the year's deeper negative readings; at -8.9 the spread says retail investors still lean pessimistic.
AAII's historical extremes
The survey's power comes from its extremes, and the two records are textbook contrarian tells. Bullishness hit an all-time high of 75.0% on January 6, 2000, days before the dot-com bubble began to burst. Bearishness peaked at 70.3% on March 5, 2009, essentially the bottom of the financial crisis (see the table below).
In both cases the crowd was most confident exactly when it should have been fearful, and most terrified right before a historic rally. That is why sentiment is a fade-the-crowd tool: it works best when readings are stretched, not when they hover near their averages.
| Extreme | Reading | When | Market context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Record bullish high | 75.0% | Jan 6, 2000 | Near the dot-com peak |
| Record bearish high | 70.3% | Mar 5, 2009 | Near the financial-crisis bottom |
| Bullish historical average | 37.5% | since 1987 | Baseline |
| Neutral historical average | 31.0% | since 1987 | Baseline |
| Bearish historical average | 31.5% | since 1987 | Baseline |
| 1-year bearish high | 53.3% | Sept 16, 2026 | Well above average |
| 1-year bullish high | 49.5% | Jan 14, 2026 | Above average |
| Latest bullish | 33.3% | Nov 18, 2026 | Below average |
| Latest bearish | 42.2% | Nov 18, 2026 | Above average |
The CNN Fear & Greed Index
CNN's Fear & Greed Index compresses seven market signals (price momentum, price strength, market breadth, put/call ratios, junk-bond demand, volatility, and safe-haven demand) into a single 0-100 score. It closed at 16 on November 19, 2026, in the 'Extreme Fear' band, down from 40 a week earlier and 18 in mid-October (see the table below).
Historically the index averages about 48.8, with an all-time high of 97 and a low of 0. Through November 2026, CNN's own data shows a 2026 average of 42.0 and a range of 6 to 71, more time in fear than greed. The all-time figures are compiled by an aggregator (finhacker) rather than CNN directly, so treat those archival figures as approximate.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Latest close (Nov 19, 2026) | 16 (Extreme Fear) |
| One week earlier (Nov 12, 2026) | 40 (Fear) |
| Oct 16, 2026 | 18 (Extreme Fear) |
| July 17, 2026 | 37 (Fear) |
| All-time high | 97 |
| All-time low | 0 |
| All-time average | 48.8 |
| 2026 year-to-date average (CNN data) | 42.0 (range 6-71) |
| Days in 'Greed' (all-time) | 32% |
| Days in 'Extreme Fear' (all-time) | 15% |
The index blends 7 market indicators (momentum, price strength, breadth, put/call, junk-bond demand, volatility, safe-haven demand) on a 0-100 scale. Source: CNN Business (current and 2026 readings); all-time figures compiled by finhacker.cz (aggregator, flagged)
The VIX: Wall Street's fear gauge
The CBOE Volatility Index, the VIX, measures expected 30-day S&P 500 volatility priced into options, and it rises when investors pay up for protection. The VIX closed at 28.44 on November 19, 2026, well above its long-run median of about 17.6 (1990-2026 daily closes) and its highest close since March 27. It had averaged 16.9 in October before jumping from 16.61 to 28.18 on November 5; March, at a 25.6 average, remains 2026's most volatile month (see the chart and table below).
A low VIX signals complacency; a high one signals fear. The record high was 82.69 during the March 2020 COVID crash, and the record low was 9.14 in November 2017. A reading in the high 20s says options markets are pricing real near-term stress, in line with the extreme-fear Fear & Greed score.
| Level | Value | When |
|---|---|---|
| Record high (close) | 82.69 | March 2020 (COVID crash) |
| Record low (close) | 9.14 | November 2017 |
| Long-run median | 17.57 | daily closes, 1990-Nov 2026 |
| Typical range | 11.3-25.8 | middle of the distribution |
| June 2026 | 16.41 | monthly reading |
| July 2026 | ~15.0 | mid-month |
| March 2026 average | 25.6 | 2026's highest monthly average |
| September 2026 average | 15.8 | monthly average of daily closes |
| October 2026 average | 16.9 | monthly average of daily closes |
| Nov 5, 2026 | 28.18 | jump from 16.61 the day before |
| Nov 19, 2026 | 28.44 | latest close; highest since March 27 (31.05) |
Below ~15 is often read as complacency; above ~30 signals fear/stress. Source: Cboe VIX daily price history
Consumer confidence: the Conference Board
Consumer confidence is a different animal from market sentiment: it measures how households feel about the economy and their finances, not stocks. The Conference Board's index rose 7.5 points to 91.7 in October 2026, from a revised 84.2 in September, roughly back to June's 91.2 (see the table below).
Both halves improved. The Present Situation Index rose 8.6 points to 120.4, and the Expectations Index rose 6.9 points to 72.6, though it remains under the 80 line that has historically warned of recession. The net view of current business conditions turned positive again (+3.6%), the labor market differential widened to +5.3%, and average 12-month inflation expectations eased to 5.8% (Conference Board).
| Component | October 2026 | Change vs September | June 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Headline Confidence Index | 91.7 | +7.5 (from 84.2, revised) | 91.2 |
| Present Situation Index | 120.4 | +8.6 | 116.4 |
| Expectations Index | 72.6 | +6.9 | 74.4 |
| Labor market differential (plentiful minus hard to get) | +5.3% | +2.4 pts | n/a |
| Net view of business conditions (good minus bad) | +3.6% | +4.8 pts | n/a |
| Avg 12-month inflation expectations | 5.8% | down from 6.1% | n/a |
| Recession-warning threshold (Expectations) | 80.0 | below = warning | 80.0 |
An Expectations reading below 80 has historically flagged elevated recession risk; October's 72.6 is still under that line despite the rebound. Source: The Conference Board (1985 = 100), Oct 27, 2026 release
University of Michigan consumer sentiment
The University of Michigan's rival gauge tells a similar story of a rebound from deep lows. The final November 2026 reading was 51.5, up 7.3% from 48.0 in October and 1.0% above the 51.0 of a year earlier (U. Michigan). October's preliminary reading had been 46.3.
The current conditions index rose 5.8% to 49.4 and the expectations index 8.4% to 52.9. Year-ahead inflation expectations fell to 3.7% from 4.7%, and long-run expectations eased to 3.3% from 3.5%. Even after the rise, sentiment remains historically low.
When markets and Main Street disagree
One of the striking features of 2026 is the gap between the moods of households and markets. Through the summer and early fall, consumers were as gloomy as in past recessions while stocks hit highs; in November the roles partly flipped, as consumer gauges recovered while the VIX and the Fear & Greed Index moved into fear. Through both phases professional cash stayed under 4% and margin debt stayed near a record.
History offers no clean rule here. Weak confidence sometimes precedes recessions and sometimes marks a wall of worry that stocks climb. What sentiment analysts watch is whether the gauges converge: either the market's fear fades, or positioning comes down toward the mood in the surveys.
Professional positioning: the NAAIM Exposure Index
Retail surveys capture opinions; positioning data captures money. The NAAIM Exposure Index polls active investment managers on their actual average equity exposure, on a scale from -200% (leveraged short) to +200% (leveraged long). A 2026 reading was about 77, against a first-quarter average near 82 (via NAAIM, secondary source flagged). Since August 1, 2026, NAAIM shows the public index with a three-month delay and sells current readings by subscription.
A reading of 77 means managers were, on average, roughly three-quarters invested in stocks: constructive but not maxed out. Unlike the crowd-fade logic of retail surveys, NAAIM shows where tactical professionals are actually leaning, and mid-70s exposure is a moderately bullish stance rather than an all-in bet.
The BofA Global Fund Manager Survey
Bank of America's monthly survey of global fund managers is the institutional sentiment benchmark. In July 2026 it turned decisively bullish: average cash fell to 3.6% (from 4.1%), tripping the bank's contrarian sell signal, which fires when cash drops below 4%, and cash then hit an 'uber-low' of 3.5% in August. It held at 3.9% in September and October, then fell back to 3.6% in November as managers moved money into bonds (see the table below).
The November survey (193 panelists, $526 billion AUM) showed a net 41% overweight global equities, down from 44% in October and 49% in September, while the US overweight edged up to a net 13%. A net 32% expected lower inflation and a net 14% expected weaker growth. An AI bubble returned to the top tail risk (34%), followed by an AI hyperscaler credit event (31%), and long global semiconductors remained the most crowded trade at 39% (sources: BofA via Mace News, proprietary survey flagged).
| Metric | November 2026 | October 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Average cash level | 3.6% (record low 3.5% in Aug) | 3.9% |
| Cash 'sell signal' threshold (< 4.0%) | Still below | Below |
| Net overweight global equities | 41% | 44% (49% Sept) |
| Net overweight US equities | 13% | 11% (25% Sept) |
| Net underweight bonds | 23% | 37% (48% Sept) |
| Net expecting lower inflation | 32% | 5% |
| Net expecting weaker growth | 14% | 4% |
| Top tail risk | AI bubble, 34% | Disorderly rise in bond yields, 31% |
| Most crowded trade | Long global semiconductors, 39% | Long global semiconductors, 45% |
November survey: 193 panelists with $526 billion AUM, taken Nov 6-12, 2026. In July 2026 a record 82% named long global semiconductors the most crowded trade. Source: BofA Global Fund Manager Survey via Mace News (Nov and Oct 2026); proprietary, flagged
Margin debt: leverage at a record
How much investors borrow to buy stocks is a raw measure of greed, and it sits near an all-time high. FINRA data show margin debt peaked at a record $1.50 trillion in June 2026, dipped to $1.42 trillion in July, climbed back to $1.48 trillion in September, and eased to $1.45 trillion in October, up 22.4% from $1.18 trillion a year earlier (see the chart below).
Leverage is stretched by every yardstick: as of May 2026, margin debt was about 4.1% of GDP versus a 50-year median near 1.5%, and investors' net cash position hit a record low of about -$992 billion. Rising leverage amplifies gains on the way up and losses on the way down, which is why near-record margin debt makes contrarians uneasy (FINRA).
Options and household positioning
Options flow adds another sentiment lens. The CBOE total put/call ratio was 0.86 on July 9, 2026 (a 9-day average of 0.92), meaning slightly more puts than the norm, which contrarians read as caution rather than euphoria. The total ratio typically hovers between 0.9 and 1.0; equity-only ratios run lower.
Zoom out to households and the picture flips to greed: stocks now make up a record 45% of household financial assets, per Federal Reserve Z.1 data reported by Axios, with equities at roughly 33% of total household wealth. Americans have never had more of their money riding on the stock market.
Sentiment as a contrarian tool: what it means for you
The oldest lesson in sentiment analysis is to fade the crowd at extremes: be fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful. The trouble is that extremes are rare and hard to time. In November 2026 the signals are mixed: retail surveys, the Fear & Greed Index and the VIX read fear, but institutional cash and margin debt still point to greed.
For a long-term investor the practical move is not to trade on any single gauge but to use them as a discipline check. Near-record-low cash and near-record margin debt are reasons to make sure your own risk is deliberate: keep an emergency fund in cash, avoid leverage you cannot stomach, and rebalance toward your targets rather than chasing whichever mood the tape is in. None of this is investment advice.
VIX index points (daily closes). Recent 2026 readings vs long-run median (1990-2026) and record extremes. Source: Cboe VIX daily history.
Debit balances in customers' securities margin accounts, USD trillions, month-end. Source: FINRA margin statistics.
Frequently asked questions
What is the AAII investor sentiment survey saying now?
In the week ending November 18, 2026 the AAII survey showed 33.3% bullish, 42.2% bearish, and 24.4% neutral. Bearishness is well above its long-run average of 31.5%, so individual investors lean pessimistic, with a bull-bear spread of -8.9 points (it was -20.6 a week earlier).
What is the CNN Fear & Greed Index at right now?
The CNN Fear & Greed Index closed at 16 out of 100 on November 19, 2026, in the 'Extreme Fear' band, down from 40 a week earlier. It blends seven market signals on a 0-100 scale. Its all-time average is about 48.8, and in 2026 it has averaged 42.0, spending more time fearful than greedy.
Is a low VIX bullish or bearish?
A low VIX signals calm and can reflect complacency. It is not directly bullish or bearish, but very low readings sometimes precede volatility spikes, as in November 2026, when the VIX went from 16.61 on November 4 to 28.44 by November 19, against a long-run median of about 17.6. The record high was 82.69 in March 2020.
Why is consumer confidence so weak if the market is strong?
Consumer gauges fell to deep lows in September and October 2026 on worries over prices, jobs and business conditions, then recovered: the Conference Board index rose to 91.7 in October and Michigan sentiment to 51.5 in November, both still below average. Consumer confidence measures how households feel about the economy, which can diverge from stock prices, sometimes for long stretches.
How is investor sentiment used as a contrarian indicator?
Extreme optimism has historically clustered near market tops (AAII bullishness hit 75% in January 2000) and extreme pessimism near bottoms (bearishness hit 70.3% in March 2009). Contrarians fade the crowd at extremes, though the signal is unreliable when readings are near average.
What does record margin debt signal about sentiment?
FINRA margin debt reached a record $1.50 trillion in June 2026 and stood at $1.45 trillion in October, up 22.4% year over year. In May it was about 4.1% of GDP versus a 1.5% historical median. Heavy borrowing to buy stocks reflects greed and adds leverage that amplifies both gains and losses.
Sources
- AAII - Investor Sentiment Survey
- CNN Business - Fear & Greed Index
- Cboe - VIX daily price history
- BofA Global Fund Manager Survey, November 2026 (via Mace News)
- BofA Global Fund Manager Survey, October 2026 (via Mace News)
- The Conference Board - Consumer Confidence
- University of Michigan - Surveys of Consumers
- FINRA - Margin Statistics
- Federal Reserve - Financial Accounts (Z.1)
Figures are compiled from the primary sources above and reflect the most recent data available at the time of writing. This page is informational and not investment advice.
Related statistics
- Life Expectancy and Retirement Statistics (2026)
- Millennial Money Statistics (2026)
- Payday Loan Statistics (2026)
- Required Minimum Distribution Statistics (2026)
- Social Security Statistics (2026)
- US Tax Statistics (2026)
Browse all investing statistics.
Walnut's AI assistant can tell you what these numbers mean for the stocks you actually own. Ask it, then connect a brokerage later if you want it to read your real holdings.