MGEE vs OTTR: Which Is the Better Buy in 2026?
Last updated November 2026
Short answer
MGEE and OTTR are similarly sized, but OTTR trades noticeably cheaper on forward earnings (15.40x vs 18.81x): the market is paying up for MGEE's profile and pricing OTTR more conservatively, or for faster growth. Which you prefer comes down to the drivers you believe, and whether adding either over-concentrates what you already own.
MGEE vs OTTR: the tie-breaker metrics
Same yardstick, side by side (as of November 2026). Valuation lined up like this is most meaningful for two names in the same corner of the market, which these are. Figures are approximate; verify before investing.
| Metric | MGEE | OTTR | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|---|
| Market cap | $3.02B | $3.31B | Size. The larger name is the incumbent; the smaller has more room to grow and more to prove. |
| Forward P/E | 18.81 | 15.40 | Valuation on next year's expected earnings, the same yardstick for both. Lower is cheaper for that growth; higher means the market is paying up. |
| Trailing P/E | 18.38 | 18.86 | Valuation on the last 12 months. A big drop from trailing to forward means the market expects earnings to jump, so more growth is already in the price. |
| Beta | 0.68 | 0.42 | Volatility vs the market. Above 1 swings harder than the index; below 1 is steadier. Higher beta means bigger drawdowns to hold through. |
| Price vs 52-week range | 68% of range | 6% of range | Where today's price sits between the 52-week low and high. Near the high is momentum with less margin of safety; near the low is out of favor or a discount, depending on why. |
| Price / book | 2.04 | 1.73 | How much you pay over book value. Very high can signal an asset-light, high-return business or a rich price. |
Reading it: OTTR is the cheaper of the two on forward earnings, but cheaper is not the same as better. Pair the valuation with growth (how far the forward P/E sits below the trailing P/E) and risk (beta) before you decide.
Before you buy: how MGEE and OTTR affect your concentration
The metrics above tell you which is the marginally better business. The bigger risk for most people is not picking the slightly worse stock, it is over-concentrating. MGEE and OTTR share themes, so owning both, or adding either to what you already hold, can quietly push a large share of your portfolio into one bet.
This is the part a generic comparison page cannot answer, because it depends on what you own. Connect your brokerage and Walnut shows your real, combined MGEE and OTTR exposure, flags overlap with your existing positions, and tells you if adding one would tip you past a concentration you are comfortable with, read-only by default, with your login staying at your broker. Walnut is not an investment adviser.
What does MGE Energy (MGEE) do?
MGE Energy (Nasdaq: MGEE) is a public utility holding company headquartered in Madison, Wisconsin. Its principal subsidiary, Madison Gas and Electric, generates and distributes electricity to roughly 170,000 customers concentrated in Dane County and purchases and distributes natural gas to roughly 180,000 customers across seven south-central and western Wisconsin counties. Earnings arrive through four reporting lines: a regulated electric segment (the largest, at about $263 million of six-month 2026 revenue), a regulated gas segment (about $141 million), a small nonregulated energy business that holds interests in two coal-fired units at Oak Creek and a cogeneration plant on the UW-Madison campus, and a transmission investment segment built on an equity stake in American Transmission Company. Rates, allowed return on equity and cost recovery are set by the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin, which approved a unanimous 2026/2027 rate settlement in December 2025.
What does Otter Tail Corporation (OTTR) do?
Otter Tail Corporation is a diversified company headquartered in Fergus Falls, Minnesota, operating through three segments. Its Electric segment is a regulated utility that generates, transmits, and distributes power to customers across Minnesota, North Dakota, and South Dakota using coal, natural gas, wind, and solar. Its Manufacturing segment provides contract metal fabrication and other industrial products, and its Plastics segment makes PVC pipe through subsidiaries such as Northern Pipe Products and Vinyltech. Trailing-twelve-month revenue is roughly $1.32 billion, with the regulated utility providing predictable, rate-base-driven earnings and the two non-regulated segments adding cyclical upside and downside.
MGEE vs OTTR: how do they differ?
Both fit overlapping themes, but they are not interchangeable. The useful comparison is which set of drivers and risks you want exposure to.
- MGEE drivers: Rate base growth from the renewables and storage queue; A settled two-year rate path in Wisconsin.
- OTTR drivers: Regulated utility rate-base growth; Plastics normalization and the antitrust settlement.
Which fits which kind of investor
A faster-growing, richer-valued name usually swings harder, so it suits a longer horizon and a higher tolerance for volatility; a steadier, more cash-generative business suits a more conservative or income-minded investor. A useful test is which set of risks you could hold through a drawdown: Weather drives a meaningful share of results, since heating and cooling degree days move volumes in both segments, and a mild season is not recoverable. For OTTR, the central risk is that plastics earnings fall faster or further than expected as PVC pipe prices continue resetting, pressuring consolidated EPS during the 2026 to 2028 transition; analysts expect adjusted EPS to slip from ~$6.07 in 2026 to ~$5.33 in 2027.
MGEE or OTTR: which should you pick?
MGEE vs OTTR: the full fundamentals
MGEE. The multiple has compressed since the summer, from about 20 times trailing earnings to about 17.7 times, as the share price fell while earnings held up; consensus sees 2026 EPS near $3.99 and 2027 near $4.20. Trailing EPS still includes investment gains and higher equity-method transmission income from the first half of 2026, so it is somewhat flattered relative to pure utility operations. At about 1.9 times book and with analysts averaging a hold rating and a ~$77 target, the stock sits closer to peers than it did in August, though still at a premium.
OTTR. OTTR's trailing P/E near 20x is inflated by the one-time settlement charge; on 2026 adjusted EPS guidance the stock trades closer to 15x, still below many pure regulated utilities because the market discounts cyclical plastics earnings that are normalizing lower. Q1 2026 EPS of ~$1.73 and Q2 adjusted EPS of $1.66 both beat consensus. The valuation debate hinges on how much of the earnings base is durable utility versus fading plastics upside, and the November 2 report (consensus EPS ~$1.54) is the next data point.
Headline figures (approximate, October 2026): MGEE shows revenue (ttm) ~$752M, up ~1.1% in the latest quarter, net income (ttm) ~$150M, ~19.9% net margin, eps (ttm) ~$4.07; Q2 2026 $0.89 vs ~$0.77 expected, p/e ~17.7x trailing, ~17.2x forward; OTTR shows revenue (ttm) ~$1.32B; Q2 2026 ~$334M (roughly flat YoY), q2 2026 eps GAAP -$0.18 after a $103.5M settlement charge; adjusted $1.66 vs ~$1.50 expected, 2026 eps guidance GAAP ~$3.84 to $4.24; adjusted ~$5.68 to $6.08 (original $5.22 to $5.62), net income and margin (ttm) ~$195M; net margin ~15%, operating margin ~24%.
The bottom line: MGEE vs OTTR
MGEE and OTTR are related but distinct: same themes, different businesses and risks. Neither wins in the abstract; the right pick is whichever thesis you actually believe, sized so you are not over-concentrated in one theme. Walnut can show your combined MGEE and OTTR exposure against your real portfolio. It is not an investment adviser.
Wondering how MGEE or OTTR fits the portfolio you already own? Walnut is an AI investing app that connects your brokerage read-only and answers questions like that about your actual holdings: overlap, concentration, and how each position tracks the S&P 500. Compare the best AI portfolio analyzers or see the best AI investing apps in 2026.
Your questions about MGE Energy
Ask Walnut's AI anything about MGEE and see how it fits what you own.
FAQ
What is the difference between MGEE and OTTR?
+
MGE Energy (Nasdaq: MGEE) is a public utility holding company headquartered in Madison, Wisconsin. Otter Tail Corporation is a diversified company headquartered in Fergus Falls, Minnesota, operating through three segments. They show up together because they share investment themes, but they are different businesses, so the better fit depends on which thesis you are expressing.
Is MGEE or OTTR the better stock?
+
Neither is universally better; they suit different views and risk levels. Walnut is informational, not investment advice. Compare what each does, the tie-breaker metrics above, and the risks, then decide which fits your thesis and what you already own.
Which is cheaper, MGEE or OTTR?
+
On forward P/E (as of November 2026), MGEE trades at 18.81x and OTTR at 15.40x, so OTTR is the cheaper of the two on next year's expected earnings. A lower multiple is not automatically the better buy: a richer valuation can be justified by faster growth, and a lower one can reflect real risk. Weigh the multiple against how fast each business is compounding.
Should you own both MGEE and OTTR?
+
Because they share themes, owning both concentrates you in that theme. That can be intentional (a focused bet) or accidental (less diversification than it looks). Walnut can show your combined exposure across both, and whether adding either over-concentrates you, before you buy.
What are the risks of MGEE vs OTTR?
+
MGEE: Weather drives a meaningful share of results, since heating and cooling degree days move volumes in both segments, and a mild season is not recoverable. Regulatory outcomes are the central variable: the PSCW sets allowed return, controls whether cost overruns above previously approved Certificate of Authority levels are recovered, and applies an earnings sharing mechanism that returns excess earnings to customers. Environmental rules affecting the Elm Road units remain unsettled, with the 2024 effluent guidelines rule under federal challenge and on hold, Milwaukee County designated serious nonattainment for the 2015 ozone standard, and the EPA's February 2026 greenhouse gas repeal itself facing litigation, so the cost and timing of the coal transition is genuinely open. Financing the buildout has meant issuing stock, including a $250 million offering in May 2026 and a $100 million at-the-market program, and the roughly 2.31 million shares under unsettled forward sale agreements represent further dilution ahead of the earnings they fund. Rising interest rates are a newer pressure: the stock fell about ~11% over the three months to mid-October 2026 as yields climbed, because a ~2.85% dividend yield competes directly with Treasuries. Free cash flow over the past year was about -$207 million as capital spending ran ahead of operating cash flow, which is why external funding keeps recurring. Concentration is the quiet risk, because a single county in southern Wisconsin supplies nearly all electric revenue, leaving little to offset a local economic downturn. OTTR: The central risk is that plastics earnings fall faster or further than expected as PVC pipe prices continue resetting, pressuring consolidated EPS during the 2026 to 2028 transition; analysts expect adjusted EPS to slip from ~$6.07 in 2026 to ~$5.33 in 2027. The antitrust settlements still need court approval, and the charge shows that legal exposure in a concentrated commodity market is a real cost. Commodity and end-market cyclicality in both plastics and metal fabrication add volatility that pure regulated utilities do not carry. Heavy utility capital spending turned free cash flow negative over the trailing twelve months (about -$165 million), so funding needs rise if plastics cash falls. Regulatory outcomes on rate cases, including the pending Minnesota case, allowed returns on equity, and the pace of the energy transition can affect the Electric segment's growth. The stock can also be re-rated if investors decide to value a larger share of earnings at a lower cyclical multiple rather than a utility multiple. Weather, fuel costs, and interest rates are additional standard utility sensitivities.
Walnut is informational, not investment advice. This page is descriptive and not a recommendation to buy or sell MGEE or OTTR; figures are approximate and dated (as of November 2026). Verify current data before investing.