CIBR vs HACK: Which ETF Is Better in 2026?
Last updated October 2026
Short answer
CIBR and HACK both give you Nasdaq CTA Cybersecurity Index-style exposure, but they are built differently. CIBR leans on CRWD (8.9%) and is fairly spread out; HACK leads with AVGO (6.66%) and is fairly spread out. Their top holdings overlap about 57% by weight, so the question to settle is which construction you want; whether they count as “different funds” matters less.
What's actually inside: CIBR vs HACK
The label is the same; the portfolio is not. Their top holdings overlap about 57% by weight (10 shared names: AVGO, CRWD, PANW, CSCO, NET, FTNT). The overlap is real, but each still tilts differently, so the two are different bets under one label.
| CIBR | HACK | |
|---|---|---|
| Top holding | CRWD (8.9%) | AVGO (6.66%) |
| Top 3 weight | ~25% | ~19% |
| Concentration | fairly spread out | fairly spread out |
| Construction | market-cap-weighted | market-cap-weighted |
Overlap reflects top holdings by weight (an approximation of full-fund overlap), as of October 2026. Verify full holdings with each issuer.
What each fund tracks: index and methodology
CIBR tracks Nasdaq CTA Cybersecurity Index, and HACK tracks Prime Cyber Defense Index. Because they follow different benchmarks, the two funds screen and weight their holdings differently, and that is what produces any gap in exposure, concentration, and return between them.
On construction, CIBR is market-cap-weighted and HACK is market-cap-weighted. They share a weighting approach, so any difference comes from the underlying index.
So the funds cover similar ground under different rules. Read the holdings overlap above alongside the methodology here to see how much of the difference is real exposure versus labeling.
CIBR vs HACK: cost, size, and yield side by side
| CIBR | HACK | |
|---|---|---|
| Expense ratio | 0.58% | 0.60% |
| Fee per $10,000 / year | $58 | $60 |
| Assets under management | ~$17.3 billion | $3.3 billion |
| Dividend yield | 0.38% | 0.05% |
| Inception | July 2015 | November 2014 |
CIBR is the cheaper fund at 0.58% versus 0.60%, a gap of about $2 a year on a $10,000 holding. When two funds track the same or a very similar index, that fee gap is close to pure savings: it compounds into roughly $60 of fees avoided over 30 years on that $10,000 (more as the balance grows), with essentially no change in what you own.
On scale, CIBR holds about ~$17.3 billion and HACK about $3.3 billion. Larger funds generally trade at tighter bid-ask spreads and carry deeper options markets, which matters if you trade actively or in size; for buy-and-hold investors it rarely changes the outcome. CIBR currently pays the higher dividend yield (0.38% versus 0.05%), which shifts more of its return into cash today.
Which fund suits which investor
CIBR concentrates more weight in its largest holdings (top three about 25%), so it suits an investor who wants the theme expressed through its biggest winners and can tolerate more single-name risk. HACK spreads weight more evenly (top three about 19%), which suits an investor who wants the same theme with less dependence on any one company. Match the fund to how much concentration you actually want.
These are descriptive profiles, not recommendations. What fits you depends on your goals, horizon, and what you already own. Walnut is not an investment adviser.
Before you buy: do you already own this?
The overlap that decides most ETF purchases is not between CIBR and HACK, it is with what you already hold. ETF redundancy is invisible without looking through to the underlying holdings: you can already own most of CIBR inside a broad fund like an S&P 500 or total-market ETF and not realize it.
This is the part a generic comparison cannot answer, because it depends on your account. Connect your brokerage and Walnut looks through your funds to show your real, combined exposure, flags how much of CIBR or HACK you already own elsewhere, and tells you whether adding either just buys the same companies twice, read-only by default, with your login staying at your broker. Walnut is not an investment adviser.
What is CIBR?
CIBR tracks the Nasdaq CTA Cybersecurity Index, holding companies that build and manage security hardware and software at a 0.58% expense ratio. It blends fast-growing pure-play vendors like CrowdStrike and Zscaler with larger, more established names like Broadcom and Cisco, making it a broader and steadier cybersecurity fund than more concentrated peers such as BUG. As of October 16, 2026, CIBR's price was up 39.9% year to date and 32.2% over one year, and assets had grown to about $17.3 billion.
What is HACK?
HACK is the Amplify Cybersecurity ETF, tracking the Prime Cyber Defense Index of companies that provide cyber-security hardware, software, and services. The expense ratio is 0.60%. As the first cybersecurity ETF, it holds a relatively concentrated roster of pure-play security names, distinguishing it from broader tech or software funds that only touch the theme.
CIBR or HACK: which should you pick?
This is a choice of which bet you are making. If you want the theme concentrated in its biggest winners, the more top-heavy fund suits you; if you want the theme spread more evenly so no single name dominates, the more diversified one fits. Match the construction to your conviction, then check overlap with what you already own.
CIBR vs HACK: the full fund facts
| CIBR | HACK | |
|---|---|---|
| Fund | First Trust Nasdaq Cybersecurity ETF | Amplify Cybersecurity ETF |
| Tracks | Nasdaq CTA Cybersecurity Index | Prime Cyber Defense Index |
| Expense ratio | 0.58% | 0.60% |
| Dividend yield | 0.38% | 0.05% |
| AUM | ~$17.3 billion | $3.3 billion |
| Top holding | CRWD | AVGO |
| Issuer | First Trust | Amplify ETFs |
Approximate as of October 2026; verify with each issuer.
The bottom line: CIBR vs HACK
CIBR and HACK share a theme but are built differently (about 57% overlap by weight), so pick the construction that matches your conviction. Either way, the decisive check is overlap with your real portfolio. Walnut can show that before you buy. It is not an investment adviser.
Both funds lean on CRWD, so understanding that one company explains a lot of what drives either ETF.
Wondering how CIBR or HACK fits the portfolio you already own? Walnut is an AI investing app that connects your brokerage read-only and answers questions like that about your actual holdings: overlap, concentration, and how each position tracks the S&P 500. Compare the best AI portfolio analyzers or see the best AI investing apps in 2026.
Your questions about CIBR
Ask Walnut's AI anything about CIBR and HACK and see how they fit what you own.
FAQ
What is the difference between CIBR and HACK?
+
CIBR tracks Nasdaq CTA Cybersecurity Index (0.58%); HACK tracks Prime Cyber Defense Index (0.60%). They cover similar ground but are built differently, and their top holdings overlap about 57% by weight, so the choice is about concentration and construction.
Do CIBR and HACK hold the same stocks?
+
They share 10 of their top holdings (AVGO, CRWD, PANW, CSCO, NET, FTNT), roughly 59% of CIBR and 54% of HACK by weight. There is real overlap, so owning both is less diversification than it looks. This reflects top holdings, not the full constituent lists; verify with each issuer.
Is CIBR or HACK cheaper?
+
CIBR charges 0.58% and HACK charges 0.60% as of October 2026, so CIBR keeps a little more of your return each year. On a $10,000 holding that is about $58 vs $60 a year.
Should you own both CIBR and HACK?
+
It can make sense if you want both roles, but check the overlap first so you are not paying two fees for one bet. Walnut can show the real overlap, and the overlap with what you already own, before you buy.
Which has a higher dividend yield, CIBR or HACK?
+
CIBR yields about 0.38% and HACK about 0.05% (October 2026, approximate). CIBR pays more today. For most long-term investors total return and cost matter more than the headline yield.
How much do CIBR and HACK overlap?
+
By top holdings, CIBR and HACK overlap roughly 57% by weight, sharing 10 names (AVGO, CRWD, PANW, CSCO, NET, FTNT). The overlap is meaningful, so owning both is less diversification than it appears. This uses top holdings as a proxy for the full funds; confirm with each issuer.
CIBR vs HACK: which is better?
+
They cover similar ground built differently (about 57% overlap by weight), so "better" depends on whether you want the theme concentrated in its biggest names or spread more evenly. Walnut is not an investment adviser.
Which is better for a long-term investor, CIBR or HACK?
+
Over a long horizon the deciding factors are cost and how much concentration you can hold through downturns, more than recent performance. Pick the construction you can stay invested in. Figures are approximate as of October 2026.
Related comparisons
Browse all ETF comparisons.
Walnut is informational, not investment advice. ETF figures are approximations stamped to October 2026; verify current data with each issuer before deciding. Nothing here is a recommendation.