SMH vs XSD: Which ETF Is Better in 2026?
Last updated early 2026
Short answer
SMH (MVIS US Listed Semiconductor 25) and XSD (S&P Semiconductor Select Industry Index) give you different exposures, not two versions of the same thing. SMH pays more income (~0.4%), leaning toward the ballast side; the other tilts toward growth. This is a role-and-mix decision (how much of each), not an either/or.
The tie-breaker: role, income, and risk
What each is for. SMH tracks MVIS US Listed Semiconductor 25 and XSD tracks S&P Semiconductor Select Industry Index. These play different roles in a portfolio, so ask what job you are hiring each one to do. A better recent chart does not answer that.
Income. SMH yields about ~0.4% and XSD about 0.15% (early 2026). SMH pays more income, which matters if you are drawing from the portfolio; the other leans toward price growth.
Cost. 0.35% vs 0.35% ($35 vs $35 on $10,000 a year).
How much SMH and XSD overlap
The label is the same; the portfolio is not. Their top holdings overlap about 5% by weight (1 shared names: AMD). They share a theme but hold largely different names, so they are more complementary than interchangeable.
| SMH | XSD | |
|---|---|---|
| Top holding | NVDA (~20.5%) | MXL (2.9%) |
| Top 3 weight | ~39% | ~8% |
| Concentration | moderately concentrated | fairly spread out |
| Construction | market-cap-weighted | equal-weighted |
Overlap reflects top holdings by weight (an approximation of full-fund overlap), as of early 2026. Verify full holdings with each issuer.
What each fund tracks: index and methodology
SMH tracks MVIS US Listed Semiconductor 25, and XSD tracks S&P Semiconductor Select Industry Index. Because they follow different benchmarks, the two funds screen and weight their holdings differently, and that is what produces any gap in exposure, concentration, and return between them.
On construction, SMH is market-cap-weighted and XSD is equal-weighted. That difference in method changes which companies get the most weight, even where the two funds hold many of the same names.
So these two are answering different questions about your portfolio, which is why the usual choice is how much of each to hold.
SMH vs XSD: cost, size, and yield side by side
| SMH | XSD | |
|---|---|---|
| Expense ratio | 0.35% | 0.35% |
| Fee per $10,000 / year | $35 | $35 |
| Assets under management | ~$28 billion | $3.1 billion |
| Dividend yield | ~0.4% | 0.15% |
| Inception | May 2000 | January 2006 |
The fees match exactly at 0.35%, so cost is not the deciding factor here; the difference, if any, comes from exposure and structure.
On scale, SMH holds about ~$28 billion and XSD about $3.1 billion. Larger funds generally trade at tighter bid-ask spreads and carry deeper options markets, which matters if you trade actively or in size; for buy-and-hold investors it rarely changes the outcome. SMH currently pays the higher dividend yield (~0.4% versus 0.15%), which shifts more of its return into cash today.
Which fund suits which investor
These are complements, not rivals, so most investors hold both, each in a different role. The broader or steadier fund typically works as a larger core position, while SMH, with its higher ~0.4% yield, suits a smaller satellite role for investors who specifically want that income or exposure. An income-focused or drawdown-sensitive investor weights toward the higher-yield side; a growth-focused, long-horizon investor weights toward the broader one.
These are descriptive profiles, not recommendations. What fits you depends on your goals, horizon, and what you already own. Walnut is not an investment adviser.
Before you buy: do you already own this?
The overlap that decides most ETF purchases is not between SMH and XSD, it is with what you already hold. ETF redundancy is invisible without looking through to the underlying holdings: you can already own most of SMH inside a broad fund like an S&P 500 or total-market ETF and not realize it.
This is the part a generic comparison cannot answer, because it depends on your account. Connect your brokerage and Walnut looks through your funds to show your real, combined exposure, flags how much of SMH or XSD you already own elsewhere, and tells you whether adding either just buys the same companies twice, read-only by default, with your login staying at your broker. Walnut is not an investment adviser.
What is SMH?
Tracks the MVIS US Listed Semiconductor 25 Index, with much higher concentration in the top names than the broader SOXX. NVIDIA and TSMC alone routinely account for 25-30% of the fund. Aggressive AI-infrastructure exposure for investors comfortable with concentration.
What is XSD?
XSD tracks the S&P Semiconductor Select Industry Index, a modified equal-weight benchmark of roughly 40 US-listed semiconductor companies across large, mid, and small caps. The 0.35% expense ratio is standard for a sector fund. The key nuance versus cap-weighted peers like SMH and SOXX is that XSD spreads exposure evenly, so a small designer counts nearly as much as Nvidia. As of October 16, 2026, XSD's share price was up 41.3% year to date and 36.2% over one year, though it had dropped 10.4% over the prior three months as tech stocks sold off.
SMH or XSD: which should you pick?
These are complements, not rivals. Most investors hold the broader or lower-risk fund as a larger core and use the narrower or higher-yield one as a smaller satellite sized to the role they want it to play. Holding both is the norm, so decide the split deliberately.
SMH vs XSD: the full fund facts
| SMH | XSD | |
|---|---|---|
| Fund | VanEck Semiconductor ETF | State Street SPDR S&P Semiconductor ETF |
| Tracks | MVIS US Listed Semiconductor 25 | S&P Semiconductor Select Industry Index |
| Expense ratio | 0.35% | 0.35% |
| Dividend yield | ~0.4% | 0.15% |
| AUM | ~$28 billion | $3.1 billion |
| Top holding | NVDA | MXL |
| Issuer | VanEck | State Street Investment Management (SPDR) |
Approximate as of early 2026; verify with each issuer.
VanEck specializes in thematic and sector funds. State Street SPDR launched the first US ETF and runs many sector funds.
The bottom line: SMH vs XSD
SMH and XSD are different exposures, so the question is how much of each, not which is better. Either way, the decisive check is overlap with your real portfolio. Walnut can show that before you buy. It is not an investment adviser.
Both funds lean on NVDA, so understanding that one company explains a lot of what drives either ETF.
Wondering how SMH or XSD fits the portfolio you already own? Walnut is an AI investing app that connects your brokerage read-only and answers questions like that about your actual holdings: overlap, concentration, and how each position tracks the S&P 500. Compare the best AI portfolio analyzers or see the best AI investing apps in 2026.
Your questions about SMH
Ask Walnut's AI anything about SMH and XSD and see how they fit what you own.
FAQ
What is the difference between SMH and XSD?
+
SMH tracks MVIS US Listed Semiconductor 25 (0.35%); XSD tracks S&P Semiconductor Select Industry Index (0.35%). They give you different exposure, so the choice is how much of each to hold.
Do SMH and XSD hold the same stocks?
+
They share 1 of their top holdings (AMD), roughly 6% of SMH and 3% of XSD by weight. They are more complementary than redundant. This reflects top holdings, not the full constituent lists; verify with each issuer.
Is SMH or XSD cheaper?
+
SMH charges 0.35% and XSD charges 0.35% as of early 2026, so cost is a wash. On a $10,000 holding that is about $35 vs $35 a year.
Should you own both SMH and XSD?
+
It can make sense if you want both roles, but check the overlap first so you are not paying two fees for one bet. Walnut can show the real overlap, and the overlap with what you already own, before you buy.
Which has a higher dividend yield, SMH or XSD?
+
SMH yields about ~0.4% and XSD about 0.15% (early 2026, approximate). SMH pays more today. For most long-term investors total return and cost matter more than the headline yield.
How much do SMH and XSD overlap?
+
By top holdings, SMH and XSD overlap roughly 5% by weight, sharing 1 names (AMD). That is modest overlap, so they are more complementary than redundant. This uses top holdings as a proxy for the full funds; confirm with each issuer.
SMH vs XSD: which is better?
+
They are different exposures, so "better" is the wrong frame: the useful question is how much of each fits your portfolio, not which one to pick. Walnut is not an investment adviser.
Which is better for a long-term investor, SMH or XSD?
+
Long-term investors often hold the broader, steadier fund as a core and size the narrower or higher-yield one to the role they want it to play, holding both. Figures are approximate as of early 2026.
Related comparisons
Browse all ETF comparisons.
Walnut is informational, not investment advice. ETF figures are approximations stamped to early 2026; verify current data with each issuer before deciding. Nothing here is a recommendation.