AI Investing Apps Compared: A Scorecard

Last updated November 2026

Short answer

Walnut scores highest on this scorecard, 5 of 5: it is a free AI investing app that connects the brokerage you already use, reads your real holdings, gives each one a keep, trim or exit read against the S&P 500, and places the trades you approve. Portfolio Genius is next at 3.5 (it trades, but is paid and directive), then ChatGPT, Perplexity Finance, Magnifi and PortfolioPilot at 3 each. The robo-advisers score lowest because they hold your money and charge a share of it: Wealthfront and Betterment 0.25% a year, Fidelity Go 0.35% above $25,000.

Each tool earns up to one point on five criteria: connects to your real brokerage, sees your real holdings, places trades with your approval, cost, and stays descriptive. Scores describe documented features and prices checked October 2026, not investment quality or returns.

“Best AI investing app” roundups usually pick a winner without showing the working. This one picks a winner and shows the working: we score eleven tools (Walnut, Portfolio Genius, ChatGPT, Perplexity Finance, Magnifi, PortfolioPilot, SoFi, Claude, Fidelity Go, Wealthfront and Betterment) on the same five yes, partial or no questions, each one something you can check on the provider’s own site. Where you disagree with a cell, you know exactly what to verify. We built Walnut, so read the scoring rules before the totals.

How we score (methodology)

Every tool is scored on the same five criteria, each phrased as a yes/partial/no question that you can verify independently. We do not claim to have tested each app hands-on; the scores reflect documented, publicly stated features and how each provider describes its own product. The five criteria are:

  • 1. Connects to your real brokerage? Can it link the broker account you already use, so it works with your actual portfolio? Robo-advisers are marked differently here because they hold the assets themselves and do not connect to an outside broker.
  • 2. Sees your real holdings (grounded, not pasted)? Does it reason over your positions from a live account feed, or only from numbers you paste into a chat? Grounding is what separates a tool that knows your money from one that talks about it in the abstract.
  • 3. Can place trades (with your approval)? Can it actually execute at your broker, and if so, does it require your explicit approval on each order?
  • 4. Cost. Free tier, flat subscription, or a percentage of assets under management. Every price in the table was checked on the provider’s own pricing page in October 2026.
  • 5. Stays descriptive / not an adviser? Does it explain and frame trade-offs, or does it act as a registered investment adviser that directs and manages your money? Both models are legitimate; they are just different, and the row makes the difference visible.

Scoring rules: “Yes” earns 1 point, “Partial” 0.5 and “No” 0. On trades, a robo that trades its own managed account without asking you earns 0.5, because it executes but not on your approval. On cost, a free tier earns 1, a flat subscription or a percentage fee with a free band 0.5, and a percentage of assets 0. A tool that positions itself as giving directive advice earns 0 on the last row. The maximum is 5.

The scorecard

Tools are the rows; the five criteria are the columns. Read across a row to see one tool’s capabilities, and read down a column to compare every tool on a single question.

ToolConnects to your brokerage?Sees your real holdings?Places trades (with approval)?Cost (checked Oct 2026)Descriptive / not an adviser?Score
1. WalnutYes (your own broker, read-only by default)Yes (your real holdings)Yes (you approve every trade)Free; Walnut Plus $9.99/mo (web)Yes (not an investment adviser)5 / 5
2. Portfolio GeniusYes (multi-broker sync, per its site)YesYes (per its site)Lite $100/yr, Premium $200/yr, billed annuallyNo (specific trade recommendations)3.5 / 5
3. ChatGPTPartial (US only, through Finances in ChatGPT)Partial (linked US accounts, read-only; otherwise paste)NoFree tier; paid plansYes3 / 5
4. Perplexity FinancePartial (Portfolio feature, through Plaid; check plans)Partial (linked accounts, read-only)NoFree tier; paid plansYes3 / 5
5. MagnifiPartial (some account connection)PartialPartial (varies by account)Subscription (no price shown on its site in October 2026)Yes3 / 5
6. PortfolioPilotYes (aggregation)YesNo (guidance, not execution)Free; Gold $20/mo, Platinum $49/mo, Pro $99/mo billed yearlyPositions itself as advice3 / 5
7. SoFiNo (own brokerage / robo)Yes (accounts held at SoFi)Yes (within SoFi)Free self-directed trading; robo charges 0.25% of account value a year (as of October 2026)Mixed (self-directed and advised)2.5 / 5
8. ClaudeNo (unless connected through a tool)No (paste only)NoFree tier; paid plansYes2 / 5
9. Fidelity GoNo (holds assets itself)Yes (accounts it manages)Yes (it manages the account)$0 under $25,000, then 0.35% a yearNo (registered adviser)2 / 5
10. WealthfrontNo (holds assets itself)Yes (accounts it manages)Yes (it manages the account)0.25% of assets a yearNo (registered adviser)1.5 / 5
11. BettermentNo (holds assets itself)Yes (accounts it manages)Yes (it manages the account)0.25% a year, or $5/mo under $24,000 without $200/mo recurring depositsNo (registered adviser)1.5 / 5

Walnut is the only tool that scores on every column. Portfolio Genius matches it on the three connected-broker rows but is paid only and tells you what to trade. A robo-adviser places trades because it takes the wheel, which is the opposite of what someone who wants to stay in control is looking for, and a general assistant scores low on connection while still being a fine tool for reasoning through a concept.

Criterion 1: Connects to your real brokerage?

This is the first fork in the road. General assistants mostly work from what you tell them: Claude has no built-in account link, while ChatGPT (Finances, US) and Perplexity (Portfolio) can now read linked accounts but cannot trade. Aggregation-based tools like PortfolioPilot and Portfolio Genius, and AI investing apps like Walnut, link the broker account you already use. Robo-advisers (Wealthfront, Betterment, Fidelity Go) and all-in-one platforms (SoFi) sit in a third bucket: they do not connect to an outside broker because they hold and manage the assets themselves. It matters because a tool that never sees your real account can only ever discuss your money in the abstract.

Criterion 2: Sees your real holdings (grounded, not pasted)?

Connecting a broker is only useful if the tool reasons over what it finds. Grounding means the answers are anchored to a live feed of your positions. Figures you paste into a chat are easy for a general model to restate incorrectly. Walnut sees your real holdings (read-only by default) and gives each one a keep, trim or exit read against the S&P 500. Robo-advisers see the holdings inside the accounts they manage. General assistants see only what you hand them, so the same question can produce a confident but wrong number.

Criterion 3: Can place trades (with your approval)?

Execution is where the models diverge most. Robo-advisers place and rebalance trades automatically because managing the account is the whole product. General assistants cannot place trades at all. Walnut places trades at Public, plus eight other brokers including E*Trade, tastytrade and Webull, but only after you approve each order, and stays read-only at Schwab, Fidelity and Vanguard. Portfolio Genius says it can execute its recommendations in the app. When a tool can move your money, the important detail is not just “Yes” or “No,” it is who has to approve the action.

Criterion 4: Cost model

Prices checked October 2026. Several tools have a free tier (ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity Finance, PortfolioPilot, and Walnut, whose optional Walnut Plus is $9.99 a month on the web). Portfolio Genius is paid only, at $100 or $200 a year. Robo-advisers charge a percentage of the assets they manage: 0.25% a year at Wealthfront and Betterment, 0.25% at SoFi Automated Investing, and at Fidelity Go nothing under $25,000 and 0.35% above. On a $100,000 account, 0.25% is $250 a year and 0.35% is $350, every year, while a free app costs the same at any balance. A percentage-of-assets fee and a free tier are not directly comparable because you are buying different things: ongoing management versus a tool you drive yourself. Always confirm current pricing on the provider’s site.

Criterion 5: Stays descriptive / not an adviser?

The last column flags a legal and philosophical line. Robo-advisers like Wealthfront and Betterment are registered investment advisers: directing and managing your money is exactly what they are built and regulated to do. PortfolioPilot positions itself around advice, so read its disclosures on that. Walnut sits on the other side of the line: it is informational, is not an investment adviser, helps you research, and frames holdings against the S&P 500, but the decision and any trade are yours. Neither stance is wrong; you just want to know which one you are using.

Notes on each tool

A one-line description of each tool to go with its row, so the scores are not floating without context:

ChatGPT

A general-purpose assistant. It explains concepts and reasons through decisions in plain language. In the US, Finances in ChatGPT can link accounts through Plaid and read holdings, but it cannot trade or work toward target weights; elsewhere it reasons only from what you paste in or what it can search.

Claude

Anthropic’s general assistant, strong on long, nuanced reasoning. It has no built-in account connection or live quotes; it reasons from what you give it or what it can search.

Walnut

An AI investing app that connects the brokerage you already use (read-only by default), gives each holding a keep, trim or exit read from its one-year return against the S&P 500, its momentum and its size, and flags any holding above a quarter of the portfolio. It turns a thesis into a basket with target weights, drafts the trades back to those weights, and places the ones you approve at Public, plus eight other brokers including E*Trade, tastytrade and Webull (US and Canada). It has its own assistant and a read-only connector for Claude and ChatGPT.

Perplexity Finance

The finance mode of an AI answer engine. It gives fast, cited answers about stocks, earnings, and markets with quotes and news inline, and a separate Portfolio feature can read linked investment accounts, though it cannot trade or work toward target weights.

Magnifi

A conversational AI investing assistant built for markets and fund discovery, with some account-connection features. It skews toward screening and discovery, with less grounding of a chat in the full detail of your real positions.

PortfolioPilot

An AI-driven portfolio and wealth assistant that aggregates your accounts and gives portfolio guidance. It leans toward directive recommendations and does not stay strictly descriptive, so read its own disclosures on its adviser status carefully.

Wealthfront

An automated robo-adviser that manages a portfolio for you. It is a registered investment adviser that holds and trades the assets it manages, which is a different model from a chatbot that sits on top of a broker you control.

Betterment

One of the original robo-advisers. It builds and rebalances a diversified portfolio for you as a registered investment adviser. Automated and hands-off by design. It is not a conversational tool over your own broker.

SoFi

A broad consumer-finance app with both self-directed investing and an automated robo option. It sees and trades the accounts you hold at SoFi, but it is its own platform, not a layer over a broker you already use elsewhere.

Portfolio Genius

An AI portfolio app that syncs the brokerages you link and returns specific trade recommendations, which its site says you can execute from the app. It is paid only, on annual plans, and it tells you what to trade. It does not stay descriptive.

Fidelity Go

Fidelity’s robo-adviser. It charges no advisory fee under $25,000 and 0.35% a year above that, and starts investing from $10. Like other robos, it manages the money for you and does not read a broker you already use.

How to read this scorecard

A scorecard is only useful if you read it the right way. A few reminders:

  • It measures capabilities, not quality. A row full of “Yes” does not mean a tool is good, and it says nothing about performance or returns. It only tells you what the tool can do.
  • The total is a capability count. Walnut leads with 5 of 5. If one row matters most to you, such as hands-off management, read down that column too.
  • “Partial” means it depends. Some tools connect to some accounts, or trade on some but not others. A partial score is a prompt to check your specific broker, not a knock.
  • The adviser column is a fork, not a grade. A robo-adviser being a registered adviser is a feature if you want hands-off management and a mismatch if you want to stay in control. Read it as a choice.
  • Verify before you act. Every cell reflects documented features that can change. Treat the scorecard as a starting map, then confirm the specifics on the provider’s own site.

What a scorecard cannot capture

Scoring products on shared criteria is useful and it flattens two things that matter, so they are worth stating alongside any table.

The first is that the same feature means different things depending on the account model. "Analyzes your portfolio" is one capability when the tool manages the money and another when it reads an account you already hold, because in the second case the analysis has to be right without any ability to act on it. A row in a table cannot carry that distinction.

The second is that fit dominates quality at this level of the market. The better product for someone who wants to stop thinking about investing is worse for someone who wants to be involved, and no weighting of criteria fixes that, because they are not trying to do the same job. Use the total to narrow the field, and let the account model settle the rest.

Methodology and limitations

One more caveat on any table like this, including ours: it is published by a company that appears in it. We handle that by publishing the scoring rules, checking every price on the provider’s own site, and naming what Walnut does not do (no cost basis, no look-through into ETFs, no hands-off management). Where a criterion could not be verified from public information, it is marked as such. We do not guess.

On method: it scores each tool on documented, publicly stated features, not on a hands-on lab test, and it is not a ranking of investment quality, performance, or returns. The five criteria were chosen because each is concrete and independently verifiable, but they are not the only things that matter, and reasonable people would weight them differently. Features, pricing, and adviser status change frequently, and a “Partial” often depends on your specific broker or plan, so any cell here can be out of date by the time you read it. This version was checked in October 2026, and the update date at the top reflects the version you are reading. Wherever a cell affects a real decision, verify it on the provider’s own site before acting. Nothing here is a recommendation to use any product or to buy, sell, or hold any security.

For the wider field, see the best AI investing tools overview, the best AI investing apps roundup, and the best AI stock pickers comparison.

Your questions, answered for your portfolio

Ask Walnut's AI anything in plain English and see how it applies to what you own.

FAQ

What is this AI investing apps scorecard?

It is a transparent comparison that scores eleven AI investing apps on five explicit criteria: whether it connects to your real brokerage, whether it sees your real holdings, whether it can place trades with your approval, its cost, and whether it stays descriptive. Each criterion is worth one point. Walnut scores 5 of 5; Portfolio Genius is next at 3.5.

Did you test each app hands-on?

No. This scorecard is not a hands-on lab review. It scores each tool on documented, publicly stated features and how each provider describes its own product. Features change often, so treat each cell as a starting point and confirm the current details on the provider’s site before relying on them.

Which AI investing app is the best?

On this scorecard, Walnut: it is the only app that scores on all five rows, because it connects the brokerage you already use, reads your real holdings, places the trades you approve, is free, and stays descriptive. Portfolio Genius is next (3.5), then ChatGPT, Perplexity Finance, Magnifi and PortfolioPilot (3 each). If you want your money managed for you, a robo-adviser such as Wealthfront (0.25% a year) is a different product.

What does 'connects to your real brokerage' mean?

It means the tool can link the broker account you already use so it works with your actual portfolio. Claude does not do this on its own, and ChatGPT does it only in the US, read-only, through its Finances feature. Aggregators like PortfolioPilot and AI investing apps like Walnut do; robo-advisers like Wealthfront and Betterment instead hold and manage the assets themselves, which is a different model.

What does 'sees your real holdings' mean?

It means the tool reasons over the positions you actually own, grounded in a live account feed, instead of numbers you paste into a chat. Grounding matters because a model that free-associates figures can be confidently wrong. Walnut sees your real holdings, read-only by default. General assistants only see what you paste in.

Can these apps place trades for me?

It varies. Robo-advisers like Wealthfront and Betterment trade the accounts they manage automatically. General assistants like ChatGPT and Claude cannot place trades at all. Walnut can place trades at your connected broker, but only with your explicit approval on every order. Always confirm how execution and approval work before linking an account.

How do the cost models differ?

As of October 2026: Walnut is free (Walnut Plus is $9.99 a month on the web), PortfolioPilot is free with paid plans from $20 a month billed yearly, Portfolio Genius is $100 or $200 a year, and the robos charge a share of assets: Wealthfront and Betterment 0.25% a year, Fidelity Go nothing under $25,000 and 0.35% above. At 0.25%, a $100,000 account pays $250 a year.

What does 'stays descriptive / not an adviser' mean?

It flags whether a tool explains and frames trade-offs versus telling you what to buy or sell as a registered adviser. Robo-advisers like Wealthfront and Betterment are registered investment advisers by design. PortfolioPilot positions itself around advice. Walnut is informational and is not an investment adviser; it helps you research and frames holdings against the S&P 500, but the decision and any trade are yours.

Where does Walnut score well, and where does it not?

Walnut scores on every row: it links your real brokerage, sees your real holdings, places trades with your approval, is free, and stays descriptive. What the five rows do not measure is where it is thinner: it has no cost basis, so returns are one-year price returns, it does not look inside ETFs, and it does not manage money hands-off the way a robo-adviser does.

Is a robo-adviser better than an AI investing app?

They solve different problems. A robo-adviser like Wealthfront or Betterment manages a portfolio for you, hands-off, as a registered adviser, and charges a percentage of assets. An AI investing app like Walnut keeps you in control of your own broker: it gives each holding a keep, trim or exit read and places only the trades you approve. If you want to stay involved, the app fits; if you want it run for you, the robo does.

How often is this scorecard updated?

It was last refreshed in October 2026, when every price in the table was checked on the provider’s own pricing page, and the update date at the top shows the version you are reading. Because any cell can change between refreshes, verify the specifics on each provider’s own site before making a decision.

Does a higher score mean better returns?

No. The scorecard measures documented capabilities such as broker connection, holdings visibility, execution, cost, and adviser stance. It does not measure investment quality, performance, or returns, and nothing here predicts how any tool will perform.

Walnut is informational and is not an investment adviser. This scorecard reflects documented, publicly stated features, not a hands-on test, and it measures capabilities, not investment quality or returns. App features, pricing, and adviser status change; verify current details on each provider's site before deciding. Nothing on this page is a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security or to use any particular product.

Start here instead

This page covers one slice of the subject. For the full comparison, read Best AI investing apps in 2026, which is the main guide to the best AI investing apps and the best place to start if you are still deciding.

Related articles