M1 Finance Alternatives
Last updated November 2026
Short answer
M1 Finance is a platform for building custom portfolios, called Pies: you choose the holdings and target weights, and M1 automates the buying and rebalancing toward them, on its own brokerage. The main alternatives, by type: other robo-advisors that design and manage a portfolio for you (Wealthfront, Betterment, SoFi, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios); set-your-targets automation that runs rules-based strategies (Composer); AI assistants; and Walnut, an AI investing app that builds Pie-style target-weight baskets at the brokerage you already use. Best for keeping your own broker: Walnut. Best fully managed: Wealthfront or Betterment. Best with no advisory fee: Schwab Intelligent Portfolios. Best for rules-based automation: Composer.
M1 Finance is one of the better-known build-your-own-portfolio platforms, so “M1 Finance alternatives” is a common next search, usually because someone wants a slightly different deal: more hands-off management, rules-based automation instead of fixed weights, a broker they already use with no new account to fund, or AI that helps them decide. This guide lays out the field of alternatives (Wealthfront, Betterment, SoFi, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios, Composer, and Walnut), describes each on the same fields, and is clear about what M1 does well so the comparison is fair. Walnut is our own app, and it leads here for one reason: it keeps your existing broker.
What M1 Finance is (and why people look for alternatives)
M1 Finance is a self-directed platform built around customizable portfolios called Pies. You choose the holdings and the target weight for each, and M1 automates the buying and rebalancing toward those targets, using fractional shares so the money lands in the proportions you set. Crucially, M1 is its own broker: you open and fund an M1 account, and the trading happens there. The real strength is control plus automation: you keep the design, and M1 handles the mechanical work of keeping the portfolio on target. That combination is genuinely useful and why M1 is so widely recommended for people who want to direct their own allocation without trading by hand.
People look for alternatives for a handful of reasons. Some decide designing and maintaining a Pie is more involvement than they want and would rather a robo manage the whole thing (Wealthfront, Betterment, SoFi, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios). Some want automation that is rules-based and conditional, with no fixed target weights (Composer). And some do not want to fund a new broker at all, preferring AI that connects to the account they already use and helps them decide for themselves (Walnut). Each of those points to a different tool below. None of this is a knock on M1: it is a question of fit.
Other robo-advisors: Wealthfront, Betterment, SoFi, Schwab
If designing your own Pie is more work than you want, the most hands-off alternatives are robo-advisors. Unlike M1, they design and manage the portfolio for you. Wealthfront and Betterment are the most established, both managing a diversified ETF portfolio for a low annual fee, typically around 0.25% of assets, with tax features baked in. SoFi offers a simple managed portfolio inside its broader money app. Schwab Intelligent Portfolios charges no advisory fee but holds cash and asks for a higher minimum. All four take the design off your plate the way M1 does not. Walnut takes the other path: where Wealthfront, Betterment, SoFi, and Schwab take discretion and manage a portfolio for you, Walnut holds no money, connects the broker you already use, gives each holding a keep, trim or exit read against the S&P 500, and drafts trades you approve. Pick a robo to be fully hands-off; pick Walnut for analysis and action without handing over control.
- What Wealthfront is: A leading robo-advisor that builds and manages a diversified portfolio of low-cost ETFs for you, with automatic rebalancing and automated tax-loss harvesting, typically for a low annual fee in the region of 0.25% of assets.
- Best for: Hands-off investors who would rather a robo design and manage the whole portfolio than set their own holdings and weights the way M1 asks them to.
- How it differs from M1: M1 leaves the design to you and only automates the mechanics; Wealthfront designs and manages the portfolio for you. M1 is control plus automation on your own Pie; Wealthfront is full delegation, with tax features baked in that M1 does not provide.
- The catch: You hand over the design and pay a percentage-of-assets fee, and you cannot pick your own individual holdings the way M1 lets you. Verify the current fee and minimum on its site.
- What Betterment is: A robo-advisor that builds and manages a diversified portfolio of low-cost ETFs for you, with automatic rebalancing, goal-based planning, tax features, and access to human advisers on higher tiers, typically for a low annual fee around 0.25% of assets.
- Best for: Hands-off investors who want goal-based managed portfolios and optional human advisers, without designing and maintaining their own Pie.
- How it differs from M1: Betterment takes discretion and manages the portfolio for you around goals; M1 hands you the design and automates only the buying and rebalancing. Betterment also adds tax-loss harvesting and human-adviser access that M1 does not.
- The catch: You delegate the design and pay an asset-based fee, and there is no build-your-own-Pie control. Verify current fees, tiers, and minimums on its site.
- What SoFi Automated Investing is: SoFi's robo-advisor, which builds and manages a diversified ETF portfolio for you with automatic rebalancing, sitting inside SoFi's broader app of banking, lending, and self-directed investing products.
- Best for: People who want a simple managed portfolio with a low barrier to start and who already use, or want, SoFi's wider banking and money app.
- How it differs from M1: SoFi manages the portfolio for you as a robo; M1 hands you the Pie design and automates the mechanics. SoFi bundles a broader money app around the investing, while M1 centers on the customizable-portfolio idea.
- The catch: It offers less control over the actual holdings than M1 and fewer advanced tax features, and the experience is built to pull you into SoFi's other products. Verify the current fee structure and account types on its site.
- What Schwab Intelligent Portfolios is: Charles Schwab's robo-advisor, which builds and manages a diversified ETF portfolio for you with automatic rebalancing and charges no advisory fee, instead holding a portion of the portfolio in cash.
- Best for: People who want a managed robo portfolio with no advisory fee and who already trust the Schwab ecosystem for the rest of their accounts.
- How it differs from M1: Schwab manages a diversified portfolio for you with no advisory fee; M1 leaves the design to you and automates only the mechanics. Schwab requires a cash allocation and a higher minimum to start, where M1 centers on your self-designed Pie.
- The catch: The required cash allocation can drag long-term returns, the minimum to start is higher than many robos, and you do not design your own holdings. Verify the current minimum and cash allocation on Schwab's site.
These robos win when you want to delegate the whole portfolio and let a manager design and rebalance it for you, with no Pie to build. The differences between Wealthfront, Betterment, SoFi, and Schwab are at the edges (fee model, minimum, tax features, ecosystem), not in the core managed-portfolio idea. With the robos the question is which one you trust to run the money; with Walnut it is whether you want to keep running it yourself, with an AI read and drafted rebalancing trades, on the broker you already own. For the wider field, see the best robo-advisors of 2026 roundup.
Set-your-targets automation: Composer
The closest in spirit to M1 is another automate-toward-my-design tool. M1 holds fixed target weights in a Pie and rebalances back to them. Composer takes the idea further into rules: instead of static weights, you build conditional strategies that buy, sell, and rebalance based on signals you define. It is the alternative for people who liked M1’s automation but want it to be more active and rules-driven. Walnut sits on the same line with one change: M1 rebalances to fixed weights and Composer trades on rules, both on their own brokerage, while Walnut keeps target weights at your existing broker and places each rebalancing trade only after you approve it. If you want the machine to act alone, Composer or M1 fit; if you want to confirm each trade, Walnut does.
- What Composer is: A platform for building automated, rules-based investing strategies (called symphonies) that buy, sell, and rebalance for you based on conditions you set, with a no-code editor and an AI strategy builder, on its own brokerage accounts.
- Best for: People who liked M1's automate-toward-my-design idea but want conditional, rules-based strategies over fixed target weights in a Pie.
- How it differs from M1: Both automate toward a design you control, but M1's Pie holds fixed target weights it rebalances back to, while Composer runs conditional strategies that can shift holdings based on rules and signals. Composer is more active and rules-driven; M1 is steady targets.
- The catch: Rules-based strategies add complexity and the risk of over-optimizing, there is no financial-planning advice baked in, and trading happens in Composer's own accounts, not a broker you already use. Verify current pricing and account types on its site.
Composer wins when you want automation that responds to conditions, not fixed weights, and you are comfortable with the added complexity of rules-based strategies. Like M1, it is its own brokerage, so the trading happens there, not at a broker you already use; Walnut is the one option in this guide that does not ask you to fund a new account, since it connects your existing broker read-only by default and never takes custody of anything. For alternatives that lean on AI, see the Composer alternatives roundup.
Walnut: keep your broker, add AI
Walnut is an AI investing app and the keep-your-own-broker alternative. Where M1 is its own broker that rebalances toward the Pie you design, Walnut holds no money: it connects the brokerage you already use, read-only by default, gives each holding a keep, trim or exit read against the S&P 500, and keeps target weights for each basket you build. Ask about anything in its own assistant or in Claude and ChatGPT. You keep your account, you make every decision, and you approve every trade.
- What it is: An AI investing app that connects the brokerage you already use, gives each holding a keep, trim or exit read against the S&P 500, and turns a thesis into a basket with target weights, much like an M1 Pie. It drafts the trades back to target, places the ones you approve, and can run recurring investments from cash already at your broker. It has its own assistant and also works inside Claude and ChatGPT.
- Best for: People who like M1's target-weight Pies but want to keep the broker they already have, with an AI read on every holding and a say on every trade.
- How it differs from M1: M1 is its own broker you fund, and it rebalances toward the Pie you design on its own. Walnut is not a broker: it sits on top of the account you already hold, keeps target weights for each basket, drafts the trades that would bring it back to target, and places them only when you approve. M1 rebalances for you; Walnut proposes and you confirm.
- The catch: Walnut does not rebalance without your approval or hold your money, so each rebalance takes a tap from you. It has no cost basis or tax lots, so its returns are one-year price returns, not your profit and loss. Trading works at Public plus eight other brokers including E*Trade, tastytrade and Webull; Schwab, Fidelity, and Vanguard connect read-only. It is free to use.
Walnut wins when keeping your existing broker matters and you want an AI read plus target-weight baskets without funding a new platform. If you want to never touch the portfolio, Wealthfront, Betterment, SoFi, and Schwab Intelligent Portfolios are built for that, and Composer and M1 rebalance without asking, where Walnut waits for your approval on each trade. For more on AI-led options, see the AI robo-advisor alternatives roundup.
M1 Finance alternatives at a glance
| Alternative | Best for | Type |
|---|---|---|
| Walnut | People who like M1's target-weight Pies but want to keep the broker they already have, with an AI read on every holding and a say on every trade | AI investing app (keeps your broker) |
| Wealthfront | Hands-off investors who would rather a robo design and manage the whole portfolio than set their own holdings and weights the way M1 asks them to | Robo-advisor |
| Betterment | Hands-off investors who want goal-based managed portfolios and optional human advisers, without designing and maintaining their own Pie | Robo-advisor |
| SoFi Automated Investing | People who want a simple managed portfolio with a low barrier to start and who already use, or want, SoFi's wider banking and money app | Robo-advisor |
| Schwab Intelligent Portfolios | People who want a managed robo portfolio with no advisory fee and who already trust the Schwab ecosystem for the rest of their accounts | Robo-advisor |
| Composer | People who liked M1's automate-toward-my-design idea but want conditional, rules-based strategies over fixed target weights in a Pie | Set-your-targets automation |
How to choose an M1 Finance alternative
The quickest way to narrow it down is to decide how much you want to do yourself, because that splits the field cleanly between delegation, automation, and control.
- You want it managed for you, not a Pie to design. Wealthfront and Betterment are the closest managed robos; Schwab Intelligent Portfolios charges no advisory fee; SoFi bundles a simple managed portfolio into a broader money app.
- You liked the automation but want rules, not fixed weights. Composer runs conditional, rules-based strategies it automates for you, on its own brokerage.
- You want to keep your own broker and decide with AI help. Walnut, an AI investing app, connects the brokerage you already use, gives each holding a keep, trim or exit read, and builds target-weight baskets there with trades you approve.
Two practical checks before you commit: whether the tool is its own broker you must fund or works with one you already use, and its regulatory posture (brokerage, discretionary manager, or informational tool). For the broader field, see the best robo-advisors of 2026 roundup.
The bottom line
M1 Finance is strong at one specific job: letting you design your own portfolio of holdings and weights, then automating the buying and rebalancing toward it on its own broker. The reason to look at alternatives is almost always that you want a slightly different deal. Wealthfront, Betterment, SoFi, and Schwab Intelligent Portfolios manage the portfolio for you instead of asking you to design one. Composer keeps the automation but runs rules-based strategies, not fixed weights. And Walnut, an AI investing app, builds the same kind of target-weight portfolio at the broker you already use, with a keep, trim or exit read on each holding and every trade waiting for your approval. Best for keeping your own broker: Walnut. Best fully managed: Wealthfront or Betterment. Best for rules-based automation: Composer.
Free, on the broker you already use
Ask Walnut's AI and get an answer based on what you already own.
FAQ
What is the best alternative to M1 Finance?
Best for keeping your own broker: Walnut, an AI investing app that builds target-weight baskets like M1 Pies at the account you already have and gives each holding a keep, trim or exit read. Best fully managed: Wealthfront or Betterment. Best with no advisory fee: Schwab Intelligent Portfolios. Best inside a broader money app: SoFi. Best for rules-based automation: Composer.
Why do people look for M1 Finance alternatives?
Usually because they want a slightly different deal: more hands-off management with no Pie to design, conditional rules-based strategies instead of fixed target weights, a broker they already use with no new platform to fund, or AI that helps them analyze and decide. M1 is strong at automating toward a portfolio you design, so the reasons to leave are almost always about wanting a different category of tool. This is informational, not advice.
What is the difference between M1 Finance and a robo-advisor?
M1 hands you the design: you choose the holdings and target weights in a Pie, and M1 automates the buying and rebalancing toward them. A robo-advisor like Wealthfront or Betterment does the opposite: it designs and manages a diversified portfolio for you for a fee, including tax features M1 does not provide. M1 is control plus automation; a robo is full delegation. This is informational, not advice.
M1 Finance vs Walnut?
M1 Finance is its own broker you fund, and it rebalances toward the Pie you design on its own. Walnut is an AI investing app that holds no money; it connects the broker you already use, keeps target weights for each basket, gives each holding a keep, trim or exit read against the S&P 500, and drafts the trades back to target for you to approve. M1 rebalances for you; Walnut proposes and you confirm.
Is there a free M1 Finance alternative?
Several alternatives have free or low-cost tiers. Schwab Intelligent Portfolios charges no advisory fee, and SoFi's automated investing has a low barrier to start. Walnut is free to use and connects your existing broker, with an AI read on each of your real holdings. Free tiers and limits change, so verify current details on each provider's site.
What is an M1 Finance alternative that keeps my current broker?
M1 is its own broker, so moving to it means funding a new account. If you want to keep the broker you already use, Walnut, an AI investing app, connects your existing account read-only by default, builds target-weight baskets there, and gives each holding a keep, trim or exit read in its own assistant or in Claude and ChatGPT. You keep your account and approve every trade yourself. This is informational, not advice.
What is a more hands-off alternative to M1 Finance?
If designing and maintaining a Pie is more involvement than you want, the robo-advisors are the hands-off route: Wealthfront and Betterment design and manage a diversified portfolio for you for a low annual fee around 0.25%, Schwab Intelligent Portfolios does it with no advisory fee, and SoFi offers a simple managed portfolio inside its app. They take the design off your plate entirely. This is informational, not advice.
Composer vs M1 Finance?
Both automate toward a design you control, but they differ in how. M1's Pie holds fixed target weights it rebalances back to, while Composer runs conditional, rules-based strategies that can shift holdings based on signals you set. Composer is more active and algorithmic; M1 is steady target weights. The trade-off is flexibility versus simplicity. Verify current pricing on each site.
Can I build a portfolio with my own weights without M1?
Yes. Composer lets you build rules-based strategies it automates for you, and most self-directed brokers let you buy your chosen holdings and rebalance them yourself. Walnut sits on top of a broker you already use, turns a thesis into a basket with target weights, drafts the trades back to target, and places the ones you approve. The difference is whether rebalancing runs on its own or waits for your confirmation. This is informational, not advice.
What should I look for in an M1 Finance alternative?
Decide first whether you want to keep designing the portfolio yourself or hand it to a manager, because that splits the field between automation tools and robo-advisors. Then check whether it is its own broker or works with one you already use, the fee model and minimum, whether it automates or just advises, and its regulatory status (brokerage, discretionary manager, or informational tool). Match those to your situation. This is informational and not investment advice.
Is M1 Finance worth it?
M1 can be worth it if you want to choose your own holdings and weights but would rather not place every trade and rebalance by hand, since it automates the mechanics toward the Pie you design. Whether it fits depends on whether you want that control-plus-automation model or would rather delegate to a robo or keep your existing broker. Verify current account types and any fees on M1's site. This is informational, not advice.
Walnut is informational and is not an investment adviser. App features, pricing, regulatory status, and availability change; verify current details on each provider's site before deciding. Nothing on this page is a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security or to use any particular product.